Jersey
Contributor
Black Durgon, you share an open air kitchen with the other guests, dive package is for 3 tank fills a day (not unlimited?) and not tanks (have to wait for your tank to be filled in between?) no nitrox available. Do they do boat dives from the inn?
Carib Inn, private kitchen in rooms, really hard to get a reservation because its so well loved, house reef meh, unlimited tank fills and not tanks (have to wait for your tank to be filled in between?)and no nitrox available. Bruce sounds fantastic and I feel better having an on island resource for dive gear rental or fixes - it seems his shop is open to outsiders utilizing paid services even if you are not staying there?
For the OP, In terms of Bari being busy, I went in October, which is shoulder season and the whole island was not very busy.!
Jen - I've only visited Black Durgon and Bruce Bowkers, never stayed there. I mention them as I know from others who have stayed there they are reasonable and highly recommended. It is my understanding Black Durgon is a shared kitchen. Story is that is why public access is no longer granted - people would dive Small Wall and then help themselves to the food and beverages the guests had in fridge ~ cheeky if its true! Bruce has various options including hotel w/ kitchenette style through multi-bedroom units. They have a common grill area out under a pergola. No knowledge of tanks, both offer boat dives (BD is SSI training facility) so I'm guessing tanks are available, not sure about Nitrox. My response was predicated on OP searching for economical solutions. I offer them as alternatives to the normal Buddy-Capt Don-Den Laman-Sand $$-Divi-Plaza-Belmar-Caribbean Club seen so often. I also hear good things about Hotel Roomer, I've driven by never stopped. The local realtor websites also offer rentals of condo's, Villas and houses from the small to the OMG!!
Oh yes, Bruce is certainly available to the public and worth a visit to see his gardens and check out the Carib Inn! Had a problem reg a few years ago and everyone we asked on island referred us to Bruce, well stocked bench, he doesn't rape on price and quick turn around (not to mention he's a native New Jersey guy).
KWinter - as to the bed situation, it depends - some have twin beds that can be configured into either a king or 2 twins and some rooms have multiple full or queen beds so no need to worry about sharing with another guy. Just one more thing you need to ask in advance.