Sharkbully
Registered
Just came from there. It is actaully about a 25 - 30 minute flight.
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
Banyan Bay is just south of the center of San Pedro and is an excellent kicking-off point for local diving. You will need a boat to get to any scuba or freedive sites and the boat operators will all be geared to scuba. All the dive sites in the area are pretty similar and you probably won't have a lot of choice anyway. Just make sure the boat will do an anchor dive and not a drift dive - the latter is pretty common and you'll find it pretty difficult to freedive from.
When you say "your plane flight" leaves at 4:30pm, which plane is this and where will it leave from? If you're referring to a local puddlejumper then that's probably OK, but for an international flight you'll need much more time beforehand. Shouldn't dive shortly before an airliner flight either.
My flight from the International airport in Belize leaves at 4:05 pm....My plan would be to freedive in the morning, and get on a puddle jumper right after the dive, and head to the international airport --to get there early enough so that I do not have any huge time issues to make the 4:05 flight back to Florida. Since I will be freediving, there is no "wait time to fly" issue to worry about..
I'm sure you know far more about freediving than I do, but I've always understood that nitrogen absorption issues are the same as for scuba, given of course that you're not actually down long. It's lung over-expansion issues that are quite different for freedivers.
Would you or anyone else recommend a boat in particular, that has some experience taking real freedivers out ( as opposed to snorkelors )
Not really. We get very few freedivers here and a minimum number of paying people is required for the boat to leave dock, so you're likely to be with scuba divers
...as to a scuba boat doing a drift, I have done this off Boynton Beach florida many times, where the current is often 2 mph or faster..not a huge amount of fun because the freediver has to spend so much time on the surface getting back over the top of the scuba divers, after being blown down current after the last drop and ascent.
The problem is that the boat will (normally) follow the scuba divers and their guide, and if they wait for you they may lose sight of the scuba divers. I have given up trying to persuade dive guides (and divers) here to use a DSMB, so the problem is that until the divers pop up the boat captain won't know where they are. But most "drift" dives here are actually merely linear dives in fairly still water
But if the reef is spectacular enough, I would be fine with this....Maybe my question should be, would a dive master or good local diver be able to swim upcurrent in scuba gear, on the typical drift dive..?
Given that there is seldom much of a current here, the answer is "probably yes, but irrelevant"
..If they can do this fairly easily, then I should not have too much trouble freediving it..if they can barely maintain position against the current, then I will not want to freedive in that much current, with scuba divers who may stop or be in a very different bottom current.
There is a rule here that all divers must be accompanied by a guide, though I've not implemented that for freedivers and I doubt most other operators would. It does mean though that the boat cannot leave station above you until you've surfaced
Thanks,
Dan
Great. From your answers, my choice would be to find a boat going out with scuba divers to a reef that is 35 to 55 feet deep..in this range, it is pretty easy for me to exceed any movement/travel of the scuba diving group--ie, any place they swim to, I can keep up easily. Scuba divers swim very slowly compared to freedivers, even with the up and down issue..only big currents will negatively effect this.Hi Dan
See my answers embedded below:-
Great. From your answers, my choice would be to find a boat going out with scuba divers to a reef that is 35 to 55 feet deep..in this range, it is pretty easy for me to exceed any movement/travel of the scuba diving group--ie, any place they swim to, I can keep up easily. Scuba divers swim very slowly compared to freedivers, even with the up and down issue..only big currents will negatively effect this.
For freedivers, Pinnacles are awesome, and walls are awesome, because we can stay on them for nearly the entire duration of the drop and ascent. If nothing like this is available within half day dive trip distance, then spur and groove stuff would be fine, again, 35 to 55 feet deep will work well. I don't like 20 foot deep reefs in florida, as they tend to be baby sites....however, in Fiji I found some awesome stuff only 20 feet deep
Dan