What the Heck do I buy?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Just because someone is inexperienced, does not mean they are incompetent. In fact, there are many divers out there with thousands of dives that struggle with basic skills. Experience does not make you good. Good training does.

Agreed, that and their motivation to learn. Anything can be difficult if you attach a lot of bells and whistles. A BPW inofitself is very simple, it's all the possible modifications that can be put on that can give a diver pause. But as with almost anything else, if someone has the motivation and can put their mind to it, and especially if they are trained well to think critically and be open to new things, it can be broken down quite simply.
 
There is a plate that attaches to your tank, wing, and harness. The plate is often negatively buoyant, by a tiny bit 1lb. or a fair bit 5lb. It sits behind your buoyant lungs.

Everybody's body is different. But lungs are particularly buoyant; like a really buoyant ballon attached to an elementary school playground see-saw near the 'head end'. The BP/W plate sits behind your lungs balancing out the lungs effect on trim, making it easy for the see-saw to stay level or at any other desired orientation.

Where you put negative things affects your trim, just like where people sit on the see-saw affects the trim of the see-saw. Everyone has a different best lead distribution. To get to neutral trim, you can put lead at various parts of the harness, as it is made of 2" webbing throughout, or at various points on the plate, such as with zip ties through holes or with gorilla tape.

A BC that puts ballast by the lungs is a no-user-action-required start at getting in neutral trim. A BC that gives wide flexibility in distributing additional lead gives a great start dialing in neutral trim further. And is generally more helpful for trim than a BC with plastic behind the lungs and emphasizing big pockets down by your waist/hips for lots of lead with some afterthought trim pockets part way up the back.

It's just an elementary school playground depth of understanding. If we want to attach some harness to the see-saw, would we go with a steel frame under the ballon, or a plastic and buoyant padding frame under the ballon and pockets for some lead further away from that end of the see-saw, possibly even on the opposite half of the see-saw.

but apart from remembering to thread the crotch strap ...,
what is difficult about a PB/W?
BP/Ws come with options. Elementary school bicycles come with options. They also come as size X generic packages. There are tons of things you can do to a bike given a performance or appearance tuning catalog and shop. But you do not have to. You can get a plate, harness, wing and enough pockets for the lead you expect to need as a package. It will start you out with a fair bit of ballast in a spot that does a lot of good. If it seems not quite right, you have lots of options of where to put lead close to your body, not sticking up behind you on your tank. Care for more/less of a wing, you can change just that. More/fewer pockets, you can change just that. Want some color, get colored webbing, wing, or plate.
 
For travel, look at a Dive Rite Transpac, the soft backplate travels very well and I really don't need much weight for tropical diving...and I'm pretty floaty. Add a 20-30 pound wing and a couple of weight pockets and you're ready to go. I have a backplate rig as well, but the Transpac is the goto rig 90% of the time.

Good luck,
Jay

Both BP/wing or a TransPac are both great options. Dive Rite has also just released a new Hydrolite BC that’s a lightweight option, very similar to the TransPac. Just skinnied down on a few things and a little cheaper as well.

HydroLite BC | Dive Rite
 
There is a plate that attaches to your tank, wing, and harness. The plate is often negatively buoyant, by a tiny bit 1lb. or a fair bit 5lb. It sits behind your buoyant lungs.

Everybody's body is different. But lungs are particularly buoyant; like a really buoyant ballon attached to an elementary school playground see-saw near the 'head end'. The BP/W plate goes behind your lungs balancing out the lungs effect on trim, making it easy for the see-saw to stay level or at any other desired orientation.

Where you put negative things affects your trim, just like where people sit on the see-saw affects the trim of the see-saw. Everyone has a different best lead distribution. To get to neutral trim, you can put lead at various parts of the harness, as it is made of 2" webbing throughout, or at various points on the plate, such as with zip ties through holes or with gorilla tape.

A BC that puts ballast by the lungs is a no-user-action-required start at getting in neutral trim. A BC that gives wide flexibility in distributing additional lead gives a great start dialing in neutral trim further. And is generally more helpful for trim than a BC with plastic behind the lungs and emphasizing big pockets down by your waist/hips for lots of lead with some afterthought trim pockets part way up the back.

It's just an elementary school playground depth of understanding. If we want to attach some harness to the see-saw, would we go with a steel frame under the ballon, or a plastic and buoyant padding frame under the ballon and pockets for some lead further away from that end of the see-saw, possibly even on the opposite half of the see-saw.


BP/Ws come with options. Elementary school bicycles come with options. They also come as size X generic packages. There are tons of things you can do to a bike given a performance or appearance tuning catalog and shop. But you do not have to. You can get a plate, harness, wing and enough pockets for the lead you expect to need as a package. It will start you out with a fair bit of ballast in a spot that does a lot of good. If it seems not quite right, you have lots of options of where to put lead close to your body, not sticking up behind you on your tank. Care for more/less of a wing, you can change just that. More/fewer pockets, you can change just that. Want some color, get colored webbing, wing, or plate.
You're right but body posture is hella more important than placing 1lb here and 1lb there on your equipment.
 
Another vote for the back plate and wing.
Traveled a lot with mine and it's great, very durable and easy to set up.
Check out Halcyon and XDeep for their travel BC options.
 

Back
Top Bottom