Sorry, don't know much about watches so can't really offer much of a recommendation over these three, but they all look nice!
Anyway, in my searches I have noticed that it seems to be a choice between a more traditional watch that have a rotating bezel and is water resistant versus getting one that offer depth, temp, etc. I too want to stay with an analog watch, but like the added features. Unfortunately, it seems that watches that have the additional dive functions are also much larger. The only exception is the Citizen Promaster JP107458E, which as I posted before is only 3.0 CM (I provided link in previous post, but won't get you to the watch for some reason). I am looking for a smaller profile that would be more comfortable for everyday wear, but I suppose one trade off is the ability to read it while diving. Unfortunately, I am beginning to suffer from the effects of age on reading. So too small a watch, with the digital dive functions, might be impossible to read in the water or darker conditions?
Bill.