Everyone is different. I personally use an unbalanced piston for deco bottles. They are as simple as it gets, (one moving part) they only breathe hard when deep (where most divers don't pull deco) or when low on tank pressure, (less than 1200 psi).
Mine is ancient and still works like a champ. It breathes as well as most of my other regs until I get down to around 140' or tank pressure gets low. (Even at low tank pressure, up shallow it still works great)
I think they're a great, reliable choice for deco bottles. (They make a good primary reg for many sport divers on a budget too)
Just personal choice I suppose.