Truk trip report

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

judypots

Registered
Messages
66
Reaction score
13
Location
New Jersey, USA
# of dives
200 - 499
My husband and I went to Truk (then Yap, then Palau), in late December. We stayed at the Blue Lagoon for 5 nights. I waited to see if someone would report on the death that occured on the Thorfin liveaboard while we were at the Blue Lagoon, but since I haven't seen anything, I thought I'd post it here. About mid-way through our stay, we heard about a middle aged man who had a heart attack while on the boat (not while diving, as far as we could tell). The other passengers on the Thorfin spent the rest of their time at the Blue Lagoon. We were told that the Thorfin had no defibrillator and noone trained in CPR. I don't know if they notified anyone (either at the Blue Lagoon, or the Oddysey, the other liveaboard at Truk) in a timely fashion. The information was somewhat confused on that score. By the time the Odyssey did get to the Thorfin, there was nothing that could be done. It sounded like a complete lack of basic safety equipment and procedures on the Thorfin. I also heard from some of the folks that had been on the Thorfin that even aside from that awful event, it was not otherwise a great experience.

With respect to our experience at the Blue Lagoon and Truk, the "resort" grounds are beautiful. The rooms stink (literally) - mold and mildew. Plumbing didn't work 100% of the time, either in the room or at the restaurant. (I had some pretty embarassing situations, having to report non-flushing toilets on more than one occasion). Towels were like drying yourself with a sheet. The food was more or less edible, but the service was slow and they were often out of certain foods, such as reef fish!!! (We couldn't have it once during our stay). The grounds are overrun with tiny emaciated cats, which was particularly disturbing to me as an animal lover. The people at the resort were uniformly friendly and pleasant. It just seemed as though the owners weren't putting a dime back into the place for maintenance other than to mow the lawns.

The diving was fun, although the dive boats were basically a row-boat with a canopy tacked on. A couple of times we were offered a cup of water after a dive, but nothing else, and not all the time. The dive master seemed to know what he was doing, and as I said, we had fun and saw some interesting stuff. My husband and I both agree that we are reef divers and not wreck divers so much, so we will not be returning to Truk, but I know a lot of you guys just love it. I would recommend going with the Odyssey when you go. We met some folks who had spent their week their, and they all loved it.
 
I'm sorry to hear about the fatality, although based on what you say it sounds like the kind of thing that could happen in a shopping mall.

We were on the Thorfinn about a year ago and enjoyed it very much. The crew and dive guides were great. I had some equipment problems and they bent over backwards to help. Although I have to say, the food was not brilliant, and there wasn't really enough of it, so it did have one down side. The shower in our room was a bit on the iffy side too.

I don't know if a defibrillator on board could really be considered basic safety equipment, especially in the remote south pacific. It would be interesting to know more about the incident, but, personally until I know more I'm inclined to give them the benefit of the doubt. They seemed like a hard working and pretty well organized bunch when we were there.

All in all, it was a great experience for us, and based on your description it sounds like we had a better time than you did.

I would love to go back to Chuuk, and if I did, I think we would go back to the Thorfinn.

Regards,
 
CPR training/certification is a standard requirement for any liveaboard. Sorry no excuse.
 
I would take it one step further: CPR training/certification is a standard requirement for any [-]liveaboard[/-] serious diver, especially dive masters and instructors. Sorry no excuse.

OK, maybe you don't need to make sure your CPR-card hasn’t expired before every dive, but you should be trained and periodically review it.
 
anyone who regularly dives should be a [PADI Level] rescue diver or equivalent I think.... or minimum hold a first aid certification.

but anyway.... on the note of:

My husband and I both agree that we are reef divers and not wreck divers so much

I am assuming you were not technical diving in Truk?

I keep hearing mixed opinions on whether it is necessary to be a tech diver to experience the 'real truk' or not. if you weren't technical divers did you feel limited in what you saw?

out of my shop's trips the only one that really grabs me more due to the group of people going is Truk. In one mind i am thinking it would be really interesting and something i think i definitely should do, but thus far wrecks haven't really done much for me (albeit i haven't dived any good wrecks IMO).

anyone feel free to input on this, i do want to go, but if I'm not going to get a good experience then it's a lot of money to spend on a trip just to "tick that box" on the diving list.
 
We are not technical divers. We typically started 90 -110 ft. deep on each of our 8 dives. None of the other divers on our boats were either. One funny thing was that our dive master would say that the bottom of a particular wreck was at 100 ft. but we don't need to go down that far. Then he would proceed to immediately drop to that level. We were fine with that.

IMO if you're not that crazy about wrecks, I wouldn't make Truk my only stop. We did 4 days of diving at Truk, but it was only a short stop on our way to Palau, where we stayed for almost 2 weeks, and we also did Yap. Being from New Jersey, we wouldn't have traveled that far for Truk alone. However, we had a good time there, met some great people and are glad we went.
 
yeah, I've been to Palau (just an amazing destination!) and we are going to another location on this trip as well, not yap if memory serves me...

I think i have to go, even if i don't absolutely love it, the group and the trip leader is someone who i would trust to take care of me if anything went awry.
 
IMO if you're not that crazy about wrecks, I wouldn't make Truk my only stop. We did 4 days of diving at Truk, but it was only a short stop on our way to Palau, where we stayed for almost 2 weeks, and we also did Yap. Being from New Jersey, we wouldn't have traveled that far for Truk alone. However, we had a good time there, met some great people and are glad we went.

If you're not crazy about wrecks, best to skip Truk altogether. Of course that's why divers go to Truk. For the wrecks.;)
 
Two long time operators were being discredited while a third one was recommended because of other divers suggestion!!!!!
No one on board Thorfinn knows how perform CPR!! That is a stronge statement.
As for the lack of a defibrillator....who provided the op with the information?
 
the trip leader is someone who i would trust to take care of me if anything went awry.

lost_in_space_robot_body_1_2_2004.jpg


Danger Will Robinson!

Truk is not the place for "trust me" dives. (Not that anyplace is, really.)
 

Back
Top Bottom