That's great that you got to check off a few bucket items! Blue Ringed Octo, Pygmy seahorses, Sea Turtles and other Octopus are quite common around the area. Were you lucky enough to glimpse any sharks out near Canyons? They've been hanging out there quite a bit this spring.
Glad to hear you enjoyed the diving around Puerto Galera. It really is a nice area to dive, with many options. Fortunately(unfortunately?), with such a concentration of dive sites, and the popularity, you will find a wide range of dive shops. Now that's all well and good when you have lots of time to shop for an Operator, but not so great when you have such limited time and want to get wet as soon as possible. Glad to hear that your experience with SeaRider was good (and much better than BA).
I really like hanging out at Big Apple in the late afternoon/evenings, but I wont stay in their rooms again.
All in all, do you think you'll come back for more diving?