I just booked the Cay Sal trip for October after reading a lot of the NW Bahamas vs. Cay Sal discussion. I'm glad to see your opinion of Cay Sal. I like sharks and it seemed to be the better itinerary for that. Hopefully something other than Caribbean Reef Sharks might pass by. IF not, that's OK too. I wanted to do Socorro islands, Cocos, or Galapagos because of the many different types of sharks, but thought for a first liveaboard trip, I might just try Nekton to the Bahamas right out of Ft Lauderdale first, then work my way up to one of the others.