There is a reason to wht they say "Dont feed the Fish"

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Prudent_Rabbit

Registered
Scuba Instructor
Messages
29
Reaction score
2
Location
Thailand
# of dives
200 - 499
PHUKET: A 32-year-old Briton is recovering in hospital here after his left thumb was bitten off and eaten by a giant moray eel while he was diving at the well-known East of Eden dive site in the Similan Islands.

Matt Butcher, of Stanstead, Essex, said he had fed the 2.2-meter eel regularly over the past 18 months, and that she was well-known in the diving community for her friendliness.

“Many people dive there to see her,” he said from his bed at Bangkok Phuket Hospital. “She will swim in between your legs or curl herself around your arms. Divers often feed her scraps of food taken from their liveaboard boats. She likes sausages and will even eat fruit.”

Mr Butcher told the Gazette how, on April 18, he and his buddy, 21-year-old Becks Herbert, from Norwich in England, had descended to around 14 meters with some food for the eel.

He said, “I’ve been feeding the eel for 18 months and nothing seemed different on this occasion. She seemed quite playful, and was playing with Becks, while I took the food – a sausage wrapped in a plastic bag – from the pocket of my BCD vest and threw it to her.”

Mr Butcher said the eel (Strophidon sathete) circled round behind him and latched onto the thumb of his left hand, which was still holding the bag.

“I couldn’t get my thumb out of her mouth once she had started biting. The teeth of a moray are angled backward so she got a better grip [on my thumb] every time she bit down,” he said.

“I tried pushing the fingers of my right hand into her mouth to try and force her mouth open but she did not let go; she could taste blood by then…

“She was shaking her head from side to side, biting harder all the time. Five seconds later, my thumb just came off.

“She ate it and swam away. I didn’t even have time to reach for my knife.”

Mr Butcher and Ms Herbert surfaced and returned to their dive boat, the MV Queen Scuba.

He received first aid from Royal Thai Navy (RTN) personnel at Similan 9 Island before National Park staff took him by speedboat to Tab Lamu, whence he was transferred to Phuket.

Mr Butcher praised everyone involved in rescuing him. “They were great, everyone from the crew on board the Queen Scuba to the RTN, the park rangers and the hospital. They all knew exactly what they were doing.”

Mr Butcher, who is right-handed, has been told that surgeons may be able to transplant one of his big toes to replace his thumb.

He said that he will continue diving – although he will no longer feed eels.

He added, “I was wearing shorts during this dive, and I’m just glad that the thing didn’t swim up one of the legs and bite something else.”
 
guess he'll find it hard to thumb a dive from now on..

sorry, i had to..:D
 
He added, “I was wearing shorts during this dive, and I’m just glad that the thing didn’t swim up one of the legs and bite something else.”


At least he's got a sense of humour! But what was he thinking.....a sausage? No wonder the eel went after his finger, they look almost the same.
 
Fanciful story. I am not one to thumb my nose at good dive tale but I can’t believe this is true. It is certainly entertaining but thumbthing just doesn’t ring true… I can’t put my finger on it….. :eyebrow:
 
Funnily enough I did this same dive last month and they told us about this Moray. We didn't see it though.....probably wasn't hungry.
 
That just proves that a patty is safer than a link :D

Gary D.
 
whether it's true or not, you can't blame the eel. But I could see how this could happen.

However, you get the "juice/flavor/smell" of the meat on your hands and the fish can sense the 'grease/flavor' of it on your hands and will try to eat whatever has that taste/flavor. I have seen this.

One example of this was at "Stingray City" in Grand Cayman. They gave us frozen squid, which was greasy/oily, to feed the stingrays. While they didn't bite us or anything, they could "smell" all the oils on your hands and would go crazy swimming all over you.

Another example was someone at one of the local quarries who decided to feed the fish "hot-dogs" (like the ones you grill) just under the surface of the water. He swam down, in gear, and held up two hot dogs, one in each hand. The fish went crazy. They were like piranhas attacking the hot dogs in his hands. They were both gone in under 30 seconds. Well the fish were still hungry though the hot-dogs were gone. Well there was "hot-dog juice" on his hands, which to fish kinda look like hot dogs and well, to fish, they smelled like hot dogs also. So they started nipping on his hands thinking they were food. They guy had to stick his hands under his BC jacket to keep them from being bitten by the fish. We all got a good laugh out of it and after he surfaced even a better laugh.

So to this eel, this all looked like a big breakfast sausage to him....
 
Prudent_Rabbit:
Mr Butcher, who is right-handed, has been told that surgeons may be able to transplant one of his big toes to replace his thumb.

Interesting... Guess that'll be a conversation starter anyway... :thumb:
 
Prudent_Rabbit:
Mr Butcher, who is right-handed, has been told that surgeons may be able to transplant one of his big toes to replace his thumb.
I find this the most interesting part of the article. :11:
 

Back
Top Bottom