I'm leaving this for other women who will have this question in the future.
Another vote for a cup. I've used one since 2008 and am still using the same one so I've saved a lot of waste which is awesome. The best part is I can put it in proactively when I'm anticipating my cycle, or when ovulating. I can leave it in there for way longer than a tampon with no health risks/issues like TSS. (I leave mine in 1-1.5 days at a time when I'm really light.) The drawback is that it requires practice and has a steep learning curve to insert and remove, all without having leaking/accidents. For the first few cycles, I wore backup liners. On my heaviest days, if I think I may risk leaking due to availability of facilities or at night, I will wear Thinx as a backup.
Lifechanging!