Snap ring vs retractors

[1070man]

Wondering what everyone’s thoughts are on snap rings vs retractors. Wondering what everyone uses for attaching equipment to BCD. Example, flashlights, secondary computer, camera, etc…

I know everyone will have their own presences but was wondering why a preference for one over the other.

Thanks in advance.
Brian

 

[OTF]

Bolt snaps are far, far better.

 

[grantmac]

Boltsnap, period

 

[Tassie_Rohan]

Boltsnaps.

Clipped off on chest D rings or bungee loops inside pockets when stored, clipped off to bungee strap of wrist computer when in use.


Retractors belong to the same infamous category of items as spare airs, split fins and (gasp) round dive computers: they serve only as a subtle warning sign to more experienced divers around you....


Cheers
Rohan

 

[TNEngineer]

Bolt snaps are far, far better.

Fine, but why? The simplicity of a snap is obvious, but the convenience and safety of a retractor is tough to beat. No chance of dropping anything, just let go.

 

[Tigerpaw]

Fine, but why? The simplicity of a snap is obvious, but the convenience and safety of a retractor is tough to beat. No chance of dropping anything, just let go.

Retractors can break, or get entangled.

 

[TNEngineer]

Granted. And for expensive gear I use a sheathed coiled cable. But for lighter stuff like our primary dive lights, the retractors work exceptionally well. In fact, their spring loaded operation keeps the line tight so it doesn't entangle yet its full length is available when needed.

 

[Sascha314]

Bolt snap
Universal, simple, same for every item. No need to do something special for some equipment.
These retractors are bulky, can get entangled, break not easy to change position if needed. If notbzsed ir dangles.
No thanks.

 

[Capt Jim Wyatt]

*IF* you ever decide to go "Tec" you will not want retractors. They are bulky, they create an unacceptable entanglement hazard. Oh, and yea, you will look like a stroke with a retractor.

Boltsnaps are he way to go.

 

[TNEngineer]

How do you prevent accidental droppages? Yes, we're all very careful but things happen... another diver brushes your hand, their hose grabs your strobe, etc. What's your backup plan?