Reg Braithwaite
Contributor
This thread most definitely belongs in Basic Scuba. Or BC.
I agree that an equipment forum is a great place to discuss equipment. As to nothing "technical" about this rig, I agree with you. It is possible to perform technical activities with this rig (whether sensible or not). For example, you could fill the 130 with 30/30 for a nice dive to 95' and I do believe that diving Trimix is absolutely technical.
However, the rig itself is not technical, just the use of the rig. Likewise you could forgo the usual set of doubles for back gas in favour of an H valve for reg redundancy and decide to carry EAN100 for accelerated deco and again you'd be using this rig in a technical manner. But again it would be your activities that are technical, not the basic rig.
All that being said, I strongly suspect that arguing BP+Wing is not technical is just the narcissism of small differences. To the vast majority of the diving community, this rig is "tech," whether we agree with their definition or not ;-)
Should it be elsewhere? I think I understand where you're coming from even if I'm not as much of a purist.