Similan Islands or Komodo in February

Where should I go from here?


  • Total voters
    6

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Well, I ended up going to Indonesia for some dives at Amed, Nusa Penida, Gilis and finally Komodo.

By the time I reached Komodo I had 30+ dives.

The highlight for me was Nusa Penida. Manta Point was amazing. I saw so many huge mantas there, plus a school of dolphins passing us by. It was surreal.

I did 15 dives at Komodo. I decided to go with Scuba Junkie. It's a nice resort and a very well run operation, but if I'm totally honest I expected a lot more from Komodo. It didn't blow me away at all. Visibility was poor to mediocre on most dives and there just wasn't a whole lot of marine life compared to other dives I've done. We went to manta point twice and unlike the one at Nusa Penida we only saw one manta there in total. We saw some sharks in the distance but due to poor visibility they weren't very clear. Saw some turtles, but I saw ten times as many turtles at the Gilis and a hundred times more fish at Ko Tao. Komodo did have some really nice and colourful reefs, but also plenty of reefs that have seen better days. In terms of marine life I didn't see anything I hadn't already seen in bigger numbers at other sites.

It wasn't all bad though. Some of the drift dives were exciting, with The Cauldron / Shotgun really standing out. We did it at full moon and the current was insane. Even at the surface (with whirlpools forming); never seen anything like it. Holding onto a reef hook for dear life at Shotgun with pressure enough to press your purge button / pull your mask off, then being launched upon release definitely was a thrill that even impressed the dive masters.

But the average of 15 dives was far from spectacular. So I was probably unlucky, or maybe diving just isn't at its best there at the end of wet season.
 
Will you still be able to dive in the North Andaman? It's having a SPECTACULAR season this year. Richelieu Rock is currently better than the average sites in Komodo even in the summer. It would be a pity to miss it when you're already here.
 
Well, I ended up going to Indonesia for some dives at Amed, Nusa Penida, Gilis and finally Komodo.

By the time I reached Komodo I had 30+ dives.

The highlight for me was Nusa Penida. Manta Point was amazing. I saw so many huge mantas there, plus a school of dolphins passing us by. It was surreal.

I did 15 dives at Komodo. I decided to go with Scuba Junkie. It's a nice resort and a very well run operation, but if I'm totally honest I expected a lot more from Komodo. It didn't blow me away at all. Visibility was poor to mediocre on most dives and there just wasn't a whole lot of marine life compared to other dives I've done. We went to manta point twice and unlike the one at Nusa Penida we only saw one manta there in total. We saw some sharks in the distance but due to poor visibility they weren't very clear. Saw some turtles, but I saw ten times as many turtles at the Gilis and a hundred times more fish at Ko Tao. Komodo did have some really nice and colourful reefs, but also plenty of reefs that have seen better days. In terms of marine life I didn't see anything I hadn't already seen in bigger numbers at other sites.

It wasn't all bad though. Some of the drift dives were exciting, with The Cauldron / Shotgun really standing out. We did it at full moon and the current was insane. Even at the surface (with whirlpools forming); never seen anything like it. Holding onto a reef hook for dear life at Shotgun with pressure enough to press your purge button / pull your mask off, then being launched upon release definitely was a thrill that even impressed the dive masters.

But the average of 15 dives was far from spectacular. So I was probably unlucky, or maybe diving just isn't at its best there at the end of wet season.
I would guess you were just unlucky.
Scuba junkie has gotten some mixed reviews In the last few months though
 
I would guess you were just unlucky.
Scuba junkie has gotten some mixed reviews In the last few months though
I never dove with Scuba Junkie, but I met them at ADEX Singapore twice (2024 & 25). They always give off weird vibes for some reason…

This year, one of their staff literally ignored us.

He was busy talking with an exhibitor while we were standing there waiting to be attended to. (We didn’t want to interrupt because it’s rude)

When they finished their conversation, the guy literally looked at us, walked away, entered his booth, and stood in the middle staring into space.

Luckily, a kind lady attended to us seeing that we’re obviously interested to talk to someone.

It’s not a big deal, and probably a bit silly to write this out on a forum…. but it’s these little things that raises eyebrows, especially when the diving hasn’t even started yet.

Scuba Junkie is a “chain”, so invariably, there might be some good dive centres and some bad ones. But I’m not going to take my chances on the precious few days I have.
 

Back
Top Bottom