sharks, and thier behavior

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

DocVikingo:
Here's an article from my "Ask RSD" column of the Mar '00 issue of "Rodale's Scuba Diving":

"Do need to worry about sharks while diving?"

While statistics are not fully reliable and vary substantially across time, over the years 1990 through 1997 an average of about 9 unprovoked attacks per year on divers were reported worldwide. Slightly less than 20% proved fatal. In other words, out of the millions of dives done worldwide in each of the last 8 years, on average less than 2 divers per year died as a result of unprovoked shark attack. Death by lightening or a vending machine falling on you is far more probable. Furthermore, these attacks were much more likely to occur in some areas than others. The most numerous attacks on divers occur in the continental US, Australia and Africa (2/3rds in the Republic of South Africa), respectively. Within the US, Florida and California account equally for the majority; Hawaii has less than 1/4 the total of these two states. The Caribbean is low on the list.

Sharks, about which much remains unknown, are among the ocean's most fascinating and maligned creatures. Around for hundreds of millions years, they have changed little in the past tens of millions. The approximately 370 living species range in size from the 6" carnivorous juvenile Dwarf Sharks to the 45’+ plankton eating mature Whale Shark.

Sharks are fearsome predators due to marvelously acute sensory systems, including the ability to sense infinitesimally weak electrical fields, very low frequency sounds such those generated by escaping and struggling prey, and a sense of smell which can detect a single drop of blood in one million drops of water. While vision tends not to be nearly as well developed, some sharks have excellent sensitivity to contrast and motion, and low light acuity.

The majority of sharks pose no threat to man; only about 42 species have been implicated in attacks worldwide. Great Whites account for the majority, and these are often believed to be cases food confusion; humans are not at the top of the menu with high fat animals like seal and sea lion. Next in order are the Tiger and Bull, who some feel aggress just because the diver is in proximity.

Most shark attacks occur from below or behind and are unseen by the diver, although prior to an attack is it not uncommon for them to make increasingly closer passes, or even bump you. Sharks within the line of vision also may signal they are disturbed. This commonly takes the form of an S-shaped posture, with arching of the back, lowering of the pectoral fins, & movement of the tail to one side, and sometimes shaking of the head from side to side--you'll recognize it. If you observe this, return to the boat if possible; if not, slowly sink to the bottom or back up against a reef or wall, and remain motionless. If a shark approaches you very closely, purge your second stage in front of it, then hum deeply or yell into it. If you have no other recourse, such as when a shark starts bumping you, bang it on the snout or gills, but if possible do this only with a gloved hand or arm, or inanimate object. The skin of many sharks is quite rough and could easily draw blood from an unprotected body part. A number of protective measures have been experimented with, including certain chemicals and electrical shields, but none has proved infallible.

You can reduce the already very tiny odds of attack by: (1) not diving near fishing, and especially spearfishing; (2) diving in groups; (3) avoiding deep channels and shallow water which rapidly becomes deep; (4) not diving at dusk, dawn or after dark; (5) avoiding shiny jewelry and exposure suits with contrasting colors; (6) avoiding murky water; (7) not harassing a shark; and (8) quickly returning to the boat when a shark becomes overly inquisitive or postures.

A diver following the above suggestions has no reason for fear."

Best regards.

DocVikingo

I see from his post that Doc Vikingo has given this issue much thought as well. I suspect that all intelligent divers wonder about this issue, at least early on.

For the early-on divers, who are just beginning to think about this issue, here are some thoughts on the list from Rodales:

(1) not diving near fishing, and especially spearfishing; [blood in the ocean currents is the best way to attract a local shark, so avoiding buddies who are spearfishing is a good idea]

(2) diving in groups; [for some reason Nature seems to have programmed sharks to become interested in lone animals near the surface, and if you are alone, you are interesting to a shark, so by diving with a group of divers and staying with the group you add a large a measure of safety to your diving]

(3) avoiding deep channels and shallow water which rapidly becomes deep; [unfortunately this is sometimes where the most beautiful diving is located as well]

(4) not diving at dusk, dawn or after dark; [some sharks like the Great White of Australia, South Africa, and California are day-hunters, so it depends on where you are located]

(5) avoiding shiny jewelry and exposure suits with contrasting colors;

(6) avoiding murky water;

(7) not harassing a shark; [seems like every dive trip, there is one person in the group who cannot resist swimming up to a resting shark and tweeking its tail !]

(8) quickly returning to the boat when a shark becomes overly inquisitive or postures. [I would not return too quickly, or else you could trigger the predator response in a shark, just like running from a dog].


It is so rare to see a shark, that with time, you as a developing diver will forget the notion of sharks nearby. Most divers who have been diving 5 to 10 years or more simply do not even think about sharks at all.

If you do see a shark, then make the most out of the opportunity. I would (and have) drop down to the bottom, and get behind a rock if there is one, and watch the shark. It will either be curious about you, or disturbed by your presence, or (least likely of all) be hungry and looking for a meal. Either way, if you stop your motion, drop down and duck out of sight, it will likely lose interest in you or forget about you altogether within a few minutes.

In my case with sharks, they were agitated that we had swum into their feeding area, and they acted like we were threats to them, and they began to circle us wildly. It was clear that they were not happy with us, and that they were also not hunting us as well. It was territorial behavior on their part, apparently. We took a reciprocal course away from them, while hugging the bottom, and watched them as we left, and eventually they stopped their wild behavior, after which we did not see them anymore.
 
Shark "visits" are not rare around here at all.

As for not diving with people who spearfish, to each their own. In the two times I thought I might get bit thus far in my diving career neither of them was while spearing - in both cases I wish I had my speargun, as a camera (or an arm!) makes a rather poor deterrent to a hungry shark.

While you might attract a shark by spearing fish, you also are then armed and able to defend yourself. This is a non-trivial issue if the shark decides it wants to take a bite or three. Being unarmed in that situation is very, very bad.

The most dangerous attacks are those which come completely "out of the blue" without warning, and are almost always from behind both you and (if you have one) your buddy - in your blind spot. Sharks are very capable predators and can see far better than you can underwater - around here they are nearly always just beyond your visability when you are in the water, checking you out. The "cool places" to dive for us are also where their food sources are, you see...

If a shark is circling and agitated, that's definitely not a good thing, but at least you will have an opportunity to defend yourself if he decides to take a bite. An ambush attack will leave you no opportunity to defend yourself at all.

Remember that fear is not a good thing to display; indeed, you're arguably better off making yourself look "bigger and badder" than you really are. Making lots of loud noises (e.g. yelling into your reg), flaring your body, turning so you present a large image to the shark (rather than a thin profile) are not a bad idea. He may be interested in biting (or even eating) you, but he's not interested in LOSING a fight.
 
Yeah, the shark attack database shows that the majority of incidents occurred with solo divers, by solo sharks. That's why all my solo diving is done in freshwater!

Always keep in perspective that attacks on divers are so incredibly rare, individual ones routinely make headline news. More than half a dozen in a year would be on the high end, that makes your risk a fraction of a fraction of a percent. This is assuming the divers are not deliberately provoking the sharks.

Just take a peak at the current threads on great white sightings. These critters are so rare that spotting them outside of the handful of seal hot spots (California, South Africa) also makes the news. And as most experts will attest, almost every report exaggerates the shark's size. 22 feet is still the standard for maximum confirmed length.
 
I've seen a couple of 8'+ Bulls - once they get to be much bigger than that a big part of the reported size has to do with your eyes bugging out of your head :D
 

Back
Top Bottom