Shark attacks on a diver?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Count yourself lucky, 1st that your diving, and 2nd that you were able to see an awesome creature in it's natural habitat. While diving for a week in the Bahams, every dive we had sharks in the vicinity it was simply wonderful, I felt much more fear this past summer when I was approached by a mother bear with 2 cubs trailing....
 
i loved diving with grey reef's, white and black tips... i spent most of my dives in the GBR watching them. the grey's were 2 to 2.5m long?

but diving in bull and great white territory errks me.

diving with grey nurse shark(s) I've only ever been with one who was a very flighty pregnant female 3.5m and i was in awe as to how fast she could swim and how powerful she was through the water....
 
In my limited experience, they are pretty shy and tend to disappear when divers are around. The only exception I have seen was a pair of bull sharks who got interested in the spear fishermen we were diving with (a freshly speared Hogfish will do that!). Those two bulls followed our group for the remainder of the dive. Mostly, though, the sharks I have seen have been shy and wary of divers. I will echo the sentiment above, however, they never seem to show up when I have a camera...:dontknow:

Have fun and safe diving!

Mike
 
Ok... being a recreational scuba diver who doesn't get to go often, I've been groomed by the scuba society to believe that sharks are generally not interested in people unless harassed. On my dives, I've seen lots of reef sharks and have dove but never seen the tiger shark supposedly normally in the area. So while I respect the sharks, I don't have the fear that the movie Jaws stirred up in the American public.

That being said, I'm currently going through a book called "Unbroken" which is the (true) biography of a WWII bomber crew who survived floating in a raft. One of the major and CONSTANT threats was sharks. To the point that they couldn't be in the water without immediate attack by sharks. And that this was the general fear of many WWII flight crews of being in the ocean.

It's as if the sharks of the WWII era are different species than those of modern day recreational scuba diving.

Something is not jiving here. Anyone know what the deal is?
 
All joking aside, I think there are some things that divers can do to minimize the risks from sharks. This is what I've been told. I'm sure more knowledgable people will tell me which parts are urban myth.

1 - Sharks almost always attack from below. Therefore, if possible, get down on the bottom while you watch in awe.
2 - Watch their body language. Sharks who are feeling frisky arch their back and point their pectoral fins.
3- Never swim away from a shark. This is what prey does. You do not want to be seen as prey.
4 - If you must swim, swim directly towards a shark. This is what another predator would do, and we are, after all, supposed to be apex predators.
5 - Bubbles are wierd, unnatural and downright freaky to fish. Blowing bubbles at an approaching shark discourages it's interest.
6 - A sharks most vulnerable point is it's gills. If a shark gets too close, too aggressively, grabbing at the gills is supposed to say "I'll kill you" to the shark. And after all, sharks don't want to fight. Sharks are just like men. All they want to do is eat, sleep and reproduce...
7 - If all else fails, use your dive knife. Stab your DM. Then it doesn't matter that the shark can swim faster than you. :)

Mostly, just relax. Aggressive behaviour towards divers is exceptionally rare and most of your co-workers are, sadly, responding based less on reality than on Hollywood. I get the same thing from co-workers about sharks, eels, rays...
The only thing that has ever attacked me in the water (other than Mrs Dirty-Dog...) was a Damselfish. If they had teeth, I'd never get in the water again...
 
Ok... being a recreational scuba diver who doesn't get to go often, I've been groomed by the scuba society to believe that sharks are generally not interested in people unless harassed. On my dives, I've seen lots of reef sharks and have dove but never seen the tiger shark supposedly normally in the area. So while I respect the sharks, I don't have the fear that the movie Jaws stirred up in the American public.

That being said, I'm currently going through a book called "Unbroken" which is the (true) biography of a WWII bomber crew who survived floating in a raft. One of the major and CONSTANT threats was sharks. To the point that they couldn't be in the water without immediate attack by sharks. And that this was the general fear of many WWII flight crews of being in the ocean.

It's as if the sharks of the WWII era are different species than those of modern day recreational scuba diving.

Something is not jiving here. Anyone know what the deal is?

For one they were on the surface which is where the sharks like to feed. Second is they hace dramaticly declined in numbers thanks in part to over fishing, shark finning, people killing them for no other reason at all then fear and enjoyment and last but not least entanglement in fishing net and human trash that's been discarded into the ocean. They have come close to listing several species of sharks as endangered.

In many places people simply could not get into the water without seeing a shark now they only exist in those locations in the memories of the older generations.
 
First off, sharks kill very very few people in a given year (about 2 per year, I think). You are far more likely to be run over by a car on your way to your dive.

I live near the shark attack capital of the world: New Smyrna Beach, FL. Small sharks move in near the beach. They pursue bait fish through turbid waters and sometimes accidentally bite bathers. They leave nasty bites but nothing life threatening.

I have seen reef sharks and nurse sharks whilst diving. I can get close to nurse sharks because they are usually snoozing on the bottom. Reef sharks will circle at a distance, if I am lucky. Usually, they take a fast look and go.

It takes a pretty big shark to tackle something like a human. I would think a shark would need to be in the 14+ foot range. With the over fishing of the oceans and the relentless pursuit of shark fins, large sharks are extremely rare.

Also, remember a diver just does not look good to eat. A diver is really big - 8'+ with their fins. They have the BC and the metal tank. On top of that, they blow bubbles. Divers probably appear to be very intimidating.

I have yet to see any shark act the least bit threatening.

As I said, you would be better off worrying about things that are far more dangerous than sharks like your average car driver.
 
I appreciate everyone's response. I only expected a couple of people to respond, but with this many people responding I got lots of good input. Thanks!
 
That being said, I'm currently going through a book called "Unbroken" which is the (true) biography of a WWII bomber crew who survived floating in a raft. One of the major and CONSTANT threats was sharks. To the point that they couldn't be in the water without immediate attack by sharks. And that this was the general fear of many WWII flight crews of being in the ocean.

It's as if the sharks of the WWII era are different species than those of modern day recreational scuba diving.

Something is not jiving here. Anyone know what the deal is?

For one they were on the surface which is where the sharks like to feed. Second is they hace dramaticly declined in numbers thanks in part to over fishing, shark finning, people killing them for no other reason at all then fear and enjoyment and last but not least entanglement in fishing net and human trash that's been discarded into the ocean. They have come close to listing several species of sharks as endangered.

In many places people simply could not get into the water without seeing a shark now they only exist in those locations in the memories of the older generations.

In addition to this I would add the following:

Firstly, we know so much more about sharks now. Yes if you are floating in a raft in tropical waters you will undoubtedly see sharks, but that does not mean you are on their menu. Many people in the past, and still to this day assume anytime they see a shark their lives are in imminent danger, and this is simply not true.

Second, back in those days it was common for ships of any type to throw trash overboard. This conditioned sharks to follow ships and instantly grab whatever hit the water, which is you if your boat is sinking.

Third, ditching an airplane is not a gentle procedure, and these men were more than likely hurt, leaking bodily fluids etc. and that will of course generate more interest in predators.

Some things to consider about sharks, and this can apply to many other predators as well:

Sharks are cautious hunters, because often prey animals can be somewhat formidable themselves. Getting seriously injured is not ever on the shark's plan. People in scuba gear present a large threatening profile. In addition we are making noise that is foreign to them.

Most species are specialized feeders. Some only eat bottom creatures for example. Most are fish eaters of one sort or another. We do not look or smell or move like anything those species would consider food, avoid threatening the shark and you are never going to get bitten by them.

People are most at risk in the surf zone, especially at dusk or when the water is very murky. If you look at the motions your hands and feet make when playing in the water, and take into consideration the contrast between the darker top side and lighter underside, you can appreciate how a shark might mistake your hand or foot for a fluttering fish and take a quick nip at it. Bull sharks for example are coastal species, spend most of their lives in the same areas people swim, and even travel up rivers. This is why they are implicated in so many attacks.

Sharks that are the most concerning are ones that feed indiscriminantly and/or on prey that is about our size. Tiger sharks and white sharks are two that come to mind. When they are in clear water they are almost never a problem for divers, as we do not resemble prey. What we need to be concerned with in these encounters is that these animals may over-ride their natural cautious nature and come in for a closer look. Sharks do not have hands so naturally they grab with their mouths...bad for us. We can avoid being tested by being somewhat aggressive towards the animal, going so far as to push it away if need be.

This is just a few things. For the most part sharks really are no threat to humans, think of how many billions of people enjoy the water, shark infested waters as well, and how few get bitten.

We can easily limit what risk we do have by not going into the water in certain places and at certain times. I completely disregard all of those precautions, and have my entire life and haven't been bitten. The closest I have come was I was spy hopped by a large female tiger while I was surfing once, and this is the only time I have been afraid.

I have dived with tigers, bulls, nurse, great hammerhead, sand tigers, silkys, black tips, black nosed, zebras, browns and (supposedly) blue and threshers. I didn't see those...:depressed:

I have been in the water with wild sharks, at times with bait in the water, I have seen them surfing, I was bumped skinny dipping at night, and I dive in very close proximity with most of the above species every other Saturday in a confined space. I have been rubbed, tail whipped and even had one bump me with her nose once. I have never been bitten and only rarely felt I was in danger...I do believe those thoughts were in my head, not reality.

Sharks are big scarey creatures, but in reality they are simply animals, and they think and behave like any other. They have a bad rep because people are afraid of things that have big teeth, and things that live in the water, sharks are both. And too be honest people are not really a good judge of what animals to fear, and which ones to simply respect. Ask any pediatrician or ER doc how many kids, how many infants are bitten by the family pooch:shakehead:

Please do not fear them. Respect them certainly, but don't fear them.
 
Last edited:

Back
Top Bottom