rebreathers

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Jepuskar,

as PSP pointed out, there are dangers inherent to diving. There are additional ones inherent to Rbs. On the other side of the ledger you'll find advantages of using them, ranging rom nice (warm moist air) to there is no other way (very extended range/gas supply).

RB diving is a state of mind as much as anything else. If you do it, you have to be very disciplined, before, during and after the dive. Including willing to call a dive if there is any problem with your unit at any point.

Madmole's fatality list is a very important thing, as most people rather learn from other's mistakes than having to from their own. While I'm sure it was an eye opener, it also shows that the Inspiration is a basically sound unit. None of those accidents, as far as can be said, were caused by it. Health problems, diver's mistakes, problem with other gear, or a combination thereof ... .

There is another list containing or most part less information, but different Rbs at
http://www.metacut.com/rebreathers/users/Paul/BodyCount.htm
Read through those, too, and learn.

There are several good websites on the subject:
http://www.therebreathersite.nl/
http://www.metacut.com/

An excellent article written by Richard Pyle:
http://www.therebreathersite.nl/learner's_guide.htm
or http://www.metacut.com/rebreathers/RichPyleArticle_1.htm

Moreover, there are two books I usually recommend:
Steve Barsky's 'Simple Guide to Rebreathers' and
Jeff Bozanic's 'Mastering Rebreathers'.

As for which RB would work best for you, that depends on your diving.
The simplest RB might not be what you need or want, nor might the most expensive one fit your needs. If you read through the sites and books mentioned above, you'll get a good idea of what should work or you.
Once you've narrowed that down, try to take a 'rebreather experience' with an instructor of the unit you're intrested in. It'll give you a better idea if the unit, and RBs in general, are for you. It's fun, too. :D

Stefan
 
Thanks guys,

I think if I am going to switch to rebreathers in the future, I will start with the Draeger Dolphin. For one, its cheaper and seems to be less complicated.

My deepest dive to date is 110ft and I am perfectly ok with that...my idea of a good dive is hanging around wonderful coral formations between 30-100 feet. As of right now, I have no desire to go deeper.

Thanks for the input...you guys are certainly the minority! :)
 
Kepu, I don't dive deep either, maybe 100 feet max, but I dive with my Inspiration also, and it has been extremeley reliable and stable.

The Draeger is simplistic, and there are tons of used ones on E-Bay.

For the other naysayers, I can kill myself in my car or if flying low in my sailplane, paraglider or hang glider within seconds, sure would be alot harder to do that on my Inspiration.
 
Jepuskar, for the diving you're doing (recreational depth and time limits) the Dräger Dolphin should work well. It's a simple unit, training and parts are easily available. As it is a fairly limited unit it won't give you all that much over OC Nitrox, though. Another RB you might want to check out is the K2 SCR, as it is more capable than the Dräger. It's a RMV-keyed SCR, much like the Halcyon. Am not sure about it's availability. Here are two links, one to the manuacturer, the other to a write-up about the unit.
http://www.dnax.com/new_nav/table_k2.html
http://www.metacut.com/rebreathers/K2/Default.htm
:) Stefan
 
Iwould either go CC or stay with open circuit. While it is true there have been some deaths on the inspiration, I believe it to be a very sound unit. I have been diving breathers for almost 20 years and find the inspiration adequate for all but the most extreme dives. I think alot of people get a CC and get corvette syndrom. What I mean is if the speedo says it'll do 200 then I should do 200. If you were to get an inspiration and stay within you ability levels you would be fine. My experience with the dolphin is that the gains were not significant enough to justify the cost-Get a bigger tank.
 

Back
Top Bottom