There dont seem to be any boats with their own websites - any leads?
Also any first hand recommendations for boats.
Thanks!
Arenui, Seven Seas and Siren Fleet are all on page 1 of google search for "indonesia liveaboard", go to page 2 you get Mermaid, Sea Safari, Wallacea, Waow. Unfortunately the operators' results get lost amongst the plethora of ads and websites that focus all of their attention on getting people to book with them like liveaboard.com or Padi Travel.
You could use those sites to search for trip options and research the boats in one place and then select a few and contact the boats directly.
The price an agent advertises will be the same as the liveaboard operator. They are not allowed to offer discounts unless they have taken a full charter or there is a general special offer which you would receive from the operator when booking direct anyway.
Some agencies know the destination in detail, others not so much as they cover boats worldwide so can be hit and miss. Agencies that handle your travel as well can be very useful and tend to know more about the destination than just website based booking sites.
I've been on Indo Siren* and Damai1* and Damai2*, all are excellent boats with experienced crews. Damai wins for me in terms of service, smaller groups and food (plated not buffet) but then that comes with a higher price tag.
I've booked onto the Samambaia for a trip in 2020 and think that boat has a good balance of service quality, cabin space, experienced crew and was lower price than Indo Siren (we got a deal at the BOOT show in Germany).
*I've been on as a guest but have also worked for those companies as cruise director