Pros and cons of becoming an instructor

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

1st Sgt

New
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Location
Texas
# of dives
500 - 999
Hi, I've been a divemaster for a number of years, have recently retired from the military, and am considering becoming an instructor for a (part-time) second career. The VA might be willing to pay for my training and equipment but, as with most things government, I have a few hoops to jump through first.

My counselor gave me a list of items I must accomplish prior to approving me for the program. One of these is to interview people in the profession to see what they consider the biggest "Pros" and "Cons" of the industry/profession are. I was also told that I could not use the instructors/DMs in my LDS because that is where I plan to get my training, they are friends of mine, and their viewpoint might be biased.

Specifically, what I'm asking for is for dive professionals on this board to respond with their opinion of the best and the worst parts. If you don't mind, please add your first name and last initial and roughly (state/country) where you are located. Silly, I know, but, that's what she is asking for. Thanks for your help.
 
Trace M, 1000 Islands, NY, USA, former PDIC & PSAI int'l training director, currently a cave/tech instructor

Pros:
  • Fun job
  • Get to be around all things diving
  • Experience joys beyond your dreams
  • Office doesn't suck
  • Community support network (divers beat each other up in social media then give each other kidneys in real life)
  • Opportunities to give back to community (teach diving, volunteer on dive teams, do environmental clean ups, be involved with handicapped scuba programs, etc.)
  • Can be done professionally much longer in life due to nature of work, good work/life balance, and you are able to stand, sit, carry heavy gear, rest, lie down neutral in water, etc. You aren't just sitting at a desk or standing holding a construction stop/slow sign all day.
  • Be your own boss/operate your own business
  • Change people's lives
  • Be proud of what you do for a living
  • Meet people
  • Adventurous working conditions
  • Opportunities to self-actualize and grow personally and professionally
  • Exposure to risk (caves, wrecks, sharks, women)


Cons:
  • Low pay
  • No union
  • No job security
  • If you don't work you don't get paid
  • Declining industry
  • Depends upon booming economy since diving is a luxury sport
  • Agencies flooding market with mostly poor instructors
  • Manufacturers opening dealers in protected radii against ethical policies
  • Long hours
  • Hard work
  • Exposure to risk (high pressure cylinders, angry seas, lightning)
 
Hi, I've been a divemaster for a number of years, have recently retired from the military, and am considering becoming an instructor for a (part-time) second career. The VA might be willing to pay for my training and equipment but, as with most things government, I have a few hoops to jump through first.

My counselor gave me a list of items I must accomplish prior to approving me for the program. One of these is to interview people in the profession to see what they consider the biggest "Pros" and "Cons" of the industry/profession are. I was also told that I could not use the instructors/DMs in my LDS because that is where I plan to get my training, they are friends of mine, and their viewpoint might be biased.

Specifically, what I'm asking for is for dive professionals on this board to respond with their opinion of the best and the worst parts. If you don't mind, please add your first name and last initial and roughly (state/country) where you are located. Silly, I know, but, that's what she is asking for. Thanks for your help.

Rob T. -- The Netherlands. Diver since 1984, DM since 2003. Instructor since 2007. Technical diver since 2002. Highly addicted to scuba diving and unashamed to admit it.

To me the pro's basically boil down to two things.

1) you get to teach, which is a valuable skill to learn for now and any future endeavor you might be interested in. The training PADI gives will provide you with a good starting point to learn how to teach well but obviously like any skill, you will need to search for mentors and colleagues who can help make you better (if you are open to that). this board is a good resource for that.

In my particular case, "paying forward" to the next generation of divers (and upcoming instructors, even if they don't know it yet) was very rewarding. In fact, in my case one of my technical instructors was a former student, which gave me a unique sense of pride.

2) The fact that you're training basic skills on a regular basis means that your basic skills become as close to second nature as they can be. You grow a HUGE radar for problems and your attention starts to "snap in" to the smallest of details that could potentially escalate into something more dangerous. Developing this "radar" for problems has added an element if safety to my diving that I can't easily qualify. I'm willing to say that if I were not an instructor that I may never have developed these important skills.

To me the cons are also basically two fold

3) Some instructors stop diving. What I mean to say is that if you are an instructor who is humping his/her butt over the same 200m stretch of reef day in and day out with students in tow then you have basically stopped diving. I try to put a lot of effort into making at least as many dives of my own in a year as I do training dives. This takes time.... a LOT of time. It takes having good (and understanding) buddies around you and it takes having a VERY understanding spouse. In the end, I'm about to stop teaching (or at least take an extended hiatus) because I was starting to make too many sacrifices in other areas of my life in order to be an instructor. Scuba training is a time intensive activity if you need to combine it with other things and finding a "balance" can sometimes be difficult.

4) As a vocation, a passion, a hobby, or a unique and interesting way of life, there are few things on this planet that compare to scuba diving unless you are also an astronaut. However, and this point is about the down side.... don't let anyone tell you it's a "career" if the word "career" in your experience has anything remotely to do with making money. Almost every diving instructor I've ever met (and I know a great many) would make more money working for minimum wage at McDonald's shaking oil out of french fries than they ever made as an instructor. The most successful and active instructors I know are the ones who are rich enough to afford to be successful and active. As a way of making money it scores a big fat zero on the scale of "zero = sucks" to "-10 = abysmal". There is nothing above zero on this scale unless you are willing to stop diving (see #3).

To me the pro's outweighed the cons enough to do this work and to get a LOT of pleasure from doing doing it for 15 years. The skills, the friendships, the experiences and the pride I have from doing that makes every day of being an instructor worth every moment I put into it.

R..
 
Stuart V., Virginia, USA

Pros

- Personal satisfaction from seeing people take on challenges, overcome them, and the happiness they get, and feeling like I helped with that.
- Constantly expanding my personal network of potential dive buddies.
- Dive more than I probably would otherwise, at no cost, which helps keep my skills up.
- Access to better pricing on equipment and training (for me).

Cons

- No real pay. In the grand scheme, for me, it's roughly break-even, comparing what it costs for me to teach against the perks and benefits i get from the shop I work for.
- Exposure to liability (i.e. potential for lawsuits).
- The spectre that is always lurking in the background that one of my students could get hurt while with me or after I trained them. There's a feeling of responsibility, even well after the training is over, and even if the incident had nothing to do with my training.
- Somedays, you just have "that" customer that treats you like crap and you have to eat it and smile anyway.
- Do more diving, but less of the really fun diving I'd like to be doing. I.e. a lot more time in the pool and local quarry, but at some expense of time gone to dive in North Carolina (in my case) or wherever.
- Getting up extra early and humping a lot of tanks and other gear.
- Sticking my hands down arms and legs of wetsuits to turn them inside out (to hang to dry) and realizing that the student peed in it.
 
The low pay is certainly a con--unless you are one of the rare ones that you hear from on SB who wind up doing a lot of specialty courses (perhaps as an independent) and charging more for their expertise.
One instructor friend at the shop said at times he's sorry he didn't remain a DM--$300 per OW course and no paperwork vs. maybe $500 as an instructor with the paperwork, organizing, and all the responsibilities.
 
I became an instructor 30 years but I was also a licensed 100-ton captain. That made me a LOT more employable. I took breaks from technical work to dive until at one point, I gave up on the tech stuff.
Most of the instruction that I did was for other agencies than NAUI which was dying in the Hawaiian Islands.
I did pretty well out there after learned enough Japanese to do intro dives. Then I did my own thing as well as boat building and repair. I had free yard space and power on Oahu which helped no end.
One day, it was time to go and I liquidated businesses and emigrated back to America. After a brief non-diving sojourn in the Seattle area, I left the United States again to live in Miami, the capital of Central America.
Somewhere along this trip, I added everything up and realized that if I kept the money I spent on guns, liquor, cars, and loose women in some type of control, I would never have to work again.
So I never had to work again from my late ‘40’s. I’ve been comfortably living in my compound in Boca Raton for 16 years. It’s ok here...I just had my pond and waterfall in the backyard redone.
One thing down here....divemasters on the dive boats work for NOTHING! What a deal!
I had thought that slavery had been abolished, but once again, I was wrong. I was well-paid in Hawaii and I paid my crews well when it was my turn.
If I had only known about FREE FLabor...I could have retired even earlier.
It is kinda important to tip, but I tip everyone anyway...my doctors, attorneys, masseuses, divemasters, bartenders... you know the drill.
So go for it, if you want. Best of luck, whatever you do...
 
Ahh, you can make money at it. But most teaching might be great teachers but are terrible businessman.
 
Thanks folks. I appreciate the input.
 

Back
Top Bottom