Possibility of a 5 year moratorium being imposed on lobster fishing.

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

njdiver1

Contributor
Messages
478
Reaction score
61
Location
jersey shore
Attention New Jersey Lobster Fishermen

No doubt, many of you have read newspaper articles or heard from another fisherman about the possibility of a 5 year moratorium being imposed on lobster fishing on the Southern New England (SNE) lobster stock by the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission (ASMFC). The SNE lobster stock extends from Cape Cod to Cape Hatteras.

The most recent peer reviewed stock assessment on lobsters, which included all data through 2007, showed the SNE lobster stock to be overfished and called for a resource rebuilding program. Following the results of the peer reviewed stock assessment, the ASMFC American Lobster Technical Committee (TC), which includes representatives from all states participating in lobster fisheries, reviewed fishery dependent and independent data for 2008 and 2009 and concluded that as a result of recruitment failure in the SNE lobster stock, a 5 year moratorium is necessary to rebuild the SNE lobster stock. The TC presented this recommendation to the ASMFC American Lobster Management Board (Board) as the basis for developing an Addendum to the Interstate Fishery Management Plan for American Lobster (FMP). The Board, which decides on appropriate management and monitoring measures to be implemented, is now in the process of evaluating the recommendation of the TC and deciding potential management options for rebuilding the SNE lobster stock.

The New Jersey Division of Fish and Wildlife will be conducting two outreach meetings this fall to inform all lobster fishermen on the background of the TC’s recommendation for a 5 year moratorium, what the Board has done to date in light of this recommendation, what evaluations are on-going, the timetable for an Addendum to the FMP, and the formation of Lobster Conservation Management Teams (LCMT) for providing input on the Addendum. One outreach meeting will be held in the Shark River area to accommodate fishermen in Management Area 4 (see attached map), and the second outreach meeting will be held in the Cape May area to accommodate fishermen in Management Area 5. Fishermen from Management Area 3 should attend whichever meeting is more convenient for them.

This letter is being sent to all New Jersey Lobster Permittees, recreational lobster pot licensees and major SCUBA clubs. All of you are likely to be affected to some extent by the rebuilding program contained in the developing Addendum. Kindly call the Nacote Creek Research Station at 609-748-2020 and let us know which meeting you are likely to attend so that we may plan accordingly.


Sincerely,

Peter J. Himchak, Supervising Biologist




In response to this situation and Mr. Himchak’s letter I have arranged for him to make a presentation at our November 17th meeting. All interested parties are welcome. If you need directions please notify our Secretary by email and you will receive our November reminder with map and directions.


Rather be diving,

Glenn A. Arthur
Chairman, NJCDC
NJ Council of Diving Clubs - Home page
 
I thought this proposition got shot down.
 
The ASMFC American Lobster Management "is now in the process of evaluating the recommendation of the TC and deciding potential management options for rebuilding the SNE lobster stock." "... the American Lobster Management Board, which advises the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission on lobster rules, voted instead to consider reductions in the catch -- or no new restrictions at all."
 
The ASMFC American Lobster Management "is now in the process of evaluating the recommendation of the TC and deciding potential management options for rebuilding the SNE lobster stock." "... the American Lobster Management Board, which advises the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission on lobster rules, voted instead to consider reductions in the catch -- or no new restrictions at all."

That's a shocker.


Found this in the Wiki:

<snip>Lobstermen are unique in the US in that they are able to create their own conservation policy,<snip>


All the best, James
 
Not entirely true. Much like democracy here in the US, we are actually a republic. Appointed representatives and scientists make the fisheries decisions through various commissions and councils.
 
Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission

2010 Summer Meeting Summary

AMERICAN LOBSTER MANAGEMENT BOARD (July 22, 2010 & August 2, 2010)

Meeting Summaries, Press Releases and Motions

Meeting Summary for July 22 Meeting

On July 22 in Warwick, Rhode Island, the American Lobster Board held a special meeting to discuss rebuilding of the Southern New England (SNE) lobster stock. The Board agreed to conduct a peer review of the Technical Committee’s (TC) analysis “Recruitment Failure in the Southern New England Lobster Stock.” The National Marine Fisheries Service agreed to provide funding to support the peer review. The Board discussed TC-recommend terms of reference (TORs) for that peer review. The Board tasked the TC to consider six additional elements for the TORs for review by the Board at it’s the August meeting (see motion below). The Board received the results of the deterministic stock projection report. The report gives stock abundance estimates projected out to 2017 under different fishing exploitation and recruitment scenarios (a copy of the report will be posted on the ASMFC website by August 13). One of the major findings of that report is that under current high natural mortality levels and low recruitment, rebuilding the fishery to the target will be very difficult. Even in the absence of fishing, it is projected that the stock will not rebuild to the target level over the next ten years. Given the uncertainty regarding natural mortality, if the level of natural mortality is actually lower, there is reasonable potential to rebuild the SNE stock in the next decade. The Board had an extensive discussion on the development of the draft addendum document that will include options to begin rebuilding the stock. The Board directed the TC to examine the impacts of regulations on landings including quotas, closed areas, trap limits, seasons, and size limits. The Board also tasked the Plan Development Team to conduct further analysis on the impacts of varying exploitation levels to the stock. The Board also noted that the draft addendum could include an option for a moratorium. For more information, please contact Toni Kerns, Senior Fishery Management Plan Coordinator for Management, at tkerns@asmfc.org or at (202) 289-6400.

Motions from July 22 Meeting

Move that the Terms of Reference be drafted for review at the Summer ASMFC Meeting. (1) Specify that the review be of the April 2010 Recruitment Failure Report and the related assigned Technical Committee tasks assigned by the Board. (2) Identify specifically in list form the finding, conclusions and recommendations of the report. (3)Evaluate the stock projection model, methods, and results, provide suggestion for improvement if possible and comment on the reliability of the projections for use in SNE lobster stock management. (4)Add data tables to the document supporting the figures provided. (5) Comment on the applicability of inshore recruitment conclusions to the inshore and offshore resource. (6) Include a review of the M sensitivity analysis of the model that indicated a higher M as suggested in the projections.

Motion made by Mr. Simpson; second by Mr. Augustine. Motion carries.

Move that the Board task the Technical Committee with evaluating the impacts on landings of (1) closed season by state, LMA, and time period [1-month intervals], (2) closed areas evaluated by state, LMA and/or statistical area, (3) quota based output controls based on landings by state and LMA, (4) evaluate trap limits as an input control and determine percent landings reduction associated with levels of trap reductions, (5) male only/v-notch program, and (6) modifications to the minimum and maximum gauge size.

Motion made by Mr. Simpson, second by Mr. Culhane. Motion carries.

Move that the Plan Development Team evaluate 3 options for reductions in exploitation: (1) 75%, (2) 50%, and (3) status quo.

Motion made by Mr. Grout, second by Mr. Simpson. Motion carries.


Meeting Summary for August 2 Meeting

On August 2 in Alexandria, Virginia, the American Lobster Board met to discuss TORs for the upcoming peer review of the SNE recruitment failure report and a timeline for the draft addendum document to rebuild the lobster stock. The TC presented revised TORs based on the Board direction from the July meeting. The Board approved the TORs recommended by the TC with the addition of a TOR to addresses the ability of recruitment indices to forecast future recruitment and landings for the stock area. The other TORs include reviewing the findings and conclusions of the recruitment failure document, as well as a review of the deterministic projections. The Board also discussed the timeline for the draft addendum document. The Board agreed that depending on the timing of the peer review results, it may be necessary to hold a special meeting of the Board outside of the 3 planned meeting weeks in 2011. For more information, please contact Toni Kerns, Senior Fishery Management Plan Coordinator for Management, at tkerns@asmfc.org or at (202) 289-6400.

Motions from August 2 Meeting

Move that the Lobster Management Board accept the Terms of Reference (TOR) for the Peer Review Panel as prepared by the Technical Committee, with the exception of TOR#4, and the addition of a TOR, “Comment on the applicability of the recruitment indices to forecast future recruitment and landings to the inshore and offshore areas.”

Motion made by Mr. Lapointe, second by Mr. Augustine.

Motion carries unanimously.

http://dnr.maryland.gov/fisheries/coastal/mtgs/082410/2010SummerMeetingSummary.pdf
 
Kinda funny, at least here in Florida. #1 thing you can do to up Lobster numbers in the South East. Open up Jew Fish season for a couple of days per year. Jew Fish are everywhere now and they eat lobster. Now that man can't shoot them anymore, they really have no predator and they have to eat. They eat lobster. Lets thin some jew fish and grow our lobster numbers. Kind of a win win.
 

Back
Top Bottom