I hate idiot service techs, really do.
Ok, the Poseidon 3960 can come in 2 flavors. The Jetstream/Xstream flavor, and the Cyklon flavor. The Jetstream flavor has an IP of 123, well below what the scubapro's want, and the Cyklon has an IP of 165, well above what the Cyklons want.
Knowing they were getting used with Scubapro regulators, he should have set it to the same 138psi that the second stages want. Not sure why he thought that another service tech that isn't a Poseidon tech was going to adjust the IP of a Poseidon reg.
Word from the wise, next time you get this set serviced, mail them to Air Tech Scuba in Raleigh. Literally all they do is service scuba gear and have like 6 people on full time staff that do it. They are true experts in both Poseidon and Scubapro and will make sure that they are tuned properly together.