SharkLover
Contributor
....Palau is Gold....
Boy Scott, you sure threw Palau under the bus pretty quick

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
....Palau is Gold....
Have you been to Papua-Raja Ampat area? That is Platium....Palau is Gold.....After diving the Indo-Pacific region...I very seldom dive the Caribbean. I am going to try Little Cayman for the heck of it this year.
Well underwater looks like Hawaii....No fish....LOL....well I'll have good vis!
If Palau is a standard then you should try PNG-New Britain, or a liveaboard from PNG.
PNG is not exactly laid out like Palau as it is a big country with plenty of Islands. Also it is a less traveled area, such as New Britain that only receives about 500 visitors a year from the U.S. The reefs off PNG are stunning with a variety that is not rivaled by many if any area we've been. Since our trip to PNG, I feel somewhat the same as you do. I will say however that we have been to the Red Sea and on a liveaboard in northern Australia and these two areas do come closer to PNG diving than others. The Caribbean is not even in the ballpark in comparison. We do enjoy the Caribbean but there is nowhere near the variety of amount of coral, fish, or pelagics in comparison.
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Don't feel like the LoneRanger, we are going to Hawaii the first 2 weeks in April. Not that great of a place for the Pacific, it beats the Great Lakes in both colorful fish and visibility. There's great things to see topside and a chance to see pelagics while diving. The biggest reason we're going.....free airfare.
Any comment on whether things on the reef (coral health, number of fish, number of divers, etc) are getting better or worse over time? Did you notice any differences between your two trips?
I hope you are headed for Kona. The diving is just OK but the Manta dive compares with any of the best dives I have done anywhere in the world....in my top 5 up there with the BC.
Yes, we are headed for Kona but will have only four days to have a chance to see the Mantas, so send good mojo my way as this will be my second trip to see them, last time we were skunked! We then head to Maui for a week.