Booking thru your cruise ship, you will be on a dive with 30+ other divers. Just how much do you think you will see if you are the 22nd diver? Plus the cattleboats go to the same site day after day, which means those sites are so over-dove and damaged. This has a positive side to it for the private operators. The sites we use are in better shape and our dive groups are smaller and usually the only ones on the dive site.
We've actually thought about contracting with one cruise line, but found out that none of them will deal with us unless they get 50% of our booking. That's alot of money and the only way to make money would be to cattleboat and charge higher prices.
Remember, your private dive operations deal with cruise ship passengers everyday. They have it down to a system. IF there is a problem (ie boat breaks down) there is always a back-up plan to get you back on your ship. At least our shop has a plan.
I received this email recently from a cruise ship passenger who dove with us this month, might give you some more insight to your original question:
Last week at this time, 1/18/07, I was diving in the clear warm waters off St Thomas. Today I am back home and the outside temperature will not get above freezing.
My sister in-law, Cheryl, set this dive up for us and she was a little nervous that things might not work out for us. From the moment we were met at the pier by your dive boat until the time we were dropped off to get back on board our cruise ship everything worked out great. Making this my best dive ever.
The boat was clean and well organized, the crew was friendly and professional. The scuba gear was new and well maintained. And we were able to dive as a small group friends.
I kind of felt sorry for all those from our ship that went out on the 'cattle boat' for their scuba adventure. I've been there and done that. Even charter dives have not always gone as well they could. But I could not ask for anything better about this dive. Next time I have the opportunity to dive in St Thomas I will be going out with Admiralty Dive Center. And I will recommend you to anybody that plans on diving there. Thanks to you and your staff for a wonderful time.
Dennis, Murray Utah.