I have the QuickStick and am not really sure about the accuracy. I analyze my tanks at the shop after I get them filled and when I do it with the quick stick I never come up with the same results. Usually not way off, but enough for me to question it. It could also be operator error since the instructions are somewhat vague.
You also have to remember to adjust for temperature and humidity in the air sample that you use. If you calibrate off of a tank of known 21%, then you are fine, but if you use ambient air that is say 80 degrees with 80% humidity, then you need to adjust your calibration down to around 20.3% (there is a table in the manual).
I also use the quickstick from nuvair. I also have access to the OMS, Analox, and a few others. The quickstick is durable and simple. Continuously calibrating an analyzer (if used regularly) shouldn't be necessary.
Also, all analyzers need to be adjusted for temperature and humidity. The PO2 of air is variable with the air pressure and temperature, so of course you have to adjust for that in your calibration.
One other thing is... how do you know the "known tank of 21%" is exactly 21%? It's probably not. Most air is not 21%, but a tenth or two below 21%, as the humidity, temperature, etc are also factors when you fill the tanks.
As far as the quickstick goes. I think for the price, it's great. It always reads within a few tenths of any other analyzer. I've had mine for 3 years, and it still is accurate, and the cell is still good.