Well, much better news to report! Thank you all for the great advice. I am very glad I wrote to the board about this and got a bunch of opinions. I decided to go to the shop and talk to whoever was there about my problem. The owner wasn't there, but the store manager was. I told him what the issue was, and interestingly, he confided that his wife had taken a course from this same instructor and hadn't been too happy with him either. He told me my best option was to jump into another class the next day that was an "accelerated" class a tiny bit behind where I was. The manager offered to call my other instructor and explain the situation to him for me. The only downside is he told me I'd have to pay the $100 instructor fee to the new guy as well as the old one who I'd already paid. I was willing to do that to not have to go through an experience that would turn me off of scuba.
I jumped into the class and it was MUCH better. Even the students were better! I don't think I realized how much I disliked the first instructor's style until I got a chance to see something else. I also found out many other "little" things the first guy hadn't done (e.g., he hadn't ever had us take out our log books and thus hadn't signed off on anything I'd done!) This guy was nice, a good teacher, and made sure everyone was with him before he went on to the next thing.
When we went to the pool in the afternoon, I couldn't believe it- he had 4 divemasters with him!! I think the way they do classes there they have no required number of DMs (the other class only had 1-2 and they weren't too experienced). I commented on this to one of the DMs because since there were only 8-9 people in the class, EVERY buddy team had a DM or the instructor with them the entire time. It was great! The DM said something like "a lot of DMs like to work with this instructor, so he always has several in his classes." That says a lot to me. Also, I got all of my questions answered and wasn't made to feel stupid or like I was lagging behind. Actually, I was ahead in some things because I'd already done them, but it was good to have the extra practice. Then I heard the dreaded command to "take off your mask and swim across the pool without it and then put it back on under water." I was hoping they'd have already done this skill, but no such luck. But I did it! And I didn't breathe water or panic. Hopefully I won't ever have to do that in the ocean. I do have disposable contacts, so it's not the end of the world if I lose one or both; I'd just rather not, since I don't see too well. (I know about prescription masks, btw, but if I lose my mask, it's the same problem. Anyway, one of these days I'll probably get lasik and then it will be a moot point.)
The only negative was that one of the DMs had also been in the original class with me and wanted to interrogate me on why I'd switched classes. He obviously thought the other guy was great. I was as polite as I could be, but had to get more and more vocal about it because he was just not getting the message. It was kind of uncomfortable. Also, the first instructor has left a message at home for me to call him and tell him why I wanted to do extra pool sessions. He didn't seem to realize that I wasn't just doing another session with another class, but that I was not coming back to his. I think he's so full of himself that he's in denial. He did mention that if I had a problem with him that he wanted to know about it. Then mentioned that I should know I have to pay the new guy the $100 because "we just don't [switch classes like that]". As if it were a bad thing I was doing. I guess I'll call him, but I really have no desire to talk to him. I know it's good to give feedback, but I don't think he'll really hear it.
So, I can't say that I feel completely ready to take on the cold waters of Monterey (I'm starting to think that maybe you just feel more comfortable as you dive more), but I certainly feel a lot better about my gear and my skills and this teacher.
So, thanks everyone for your feedback and advice-- I really appreciate it!
wolfgirl
PS, no, I'm not covered in hair and I don't howl at the moon.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a0dd6/a0dd67a17ec8b6e6bcb45d7047f3d9bfe87084bb" alt="Smile :-) :-)"