Dash_Riprock once bubbled...
Mass-Diver,
This is a very interesting statement. I appreciate that you have many dry dives under your belt. I just finished dry suit training two weeks ago, and your quote completely contradicts my training. I was taught to use the dry suit for buoyancy and only add air to the BC for surface buoyancy/floatation. This technique has been working very well for me. Buoyancy and trim have never been better.
Were you formally trained to use your BC for buoyancy or did you simply find that you preferred to do it that way over time?
I took my course w/ a very well known local instructor - he told us PADI wants it taught that way (just using the suit), but, that it was bascailly stupid and he then taught us the "right way."
It makes me physically ill to think about the fact that PADI teaches this the wrong way. If you can't manage 2 air spaces, you're not ready to dive dry. Espically on deep dives - a lot of air in the suit will lead to problems (slow dumping), a good wing dumps very fast and is clearly the way to go.
Everyone is entitles to their view, but, just using the suit for bouyancy is an outdated practice and is just not right. For example, if you get into doubles (which mean you're going to prett negative at the begining of the dive - because of the weight of the extra air) you would have to add TONS of air to your suit (probably even closing the valve somewhat). Why not start out doing the right way in the first way? Sure, just using your suit on a 20' beach with a al80 might not kill you, but, it's a bad habit.
Again, one of the reasons I have such strong feelings relates to a death last winter that was tied to a DS course - sure using your suit works well in a 13' deep pool, but, if you are out on the Poling and something goes wrong, you want to be able to dump air FAST - and only BC will let you do that. Also, long burst of air (need if you are diving deep only using your DS)into a DS increase the chance (in winter) of a stuck/freeflowing valve - I woudl much rather have air freeflowing into my BC (which after pulling the inflator off) can be easily dumped than my DS. Again, you want to think about what can go wrong.