DiveMaven
Contributor
Please do yourself a BIG favor and do NOT buy any BC based solely on the recommendation of anyone. Try as many different brands and configurations as possible, then decide based on comfort and fit for YOU. What I like will be different than the next diver, who will be different than the next, etc. because we all have different bodies and preferences for fit and comfort.
I'm one of the folks who has tried a BP/W and didn't like it at all, so won't even consider going that direction. However, had I listened to everyone around here who love it and bought before I tried, I would have wasted my money and time. Unfortunately I learned this the hard way with my first BC, a jacket type. I bought it based on the recommendations of other divers and within 4 dives knew I had made a terrible mistake. Thankfully I had purchased it used and back to ebay it went where it sold quickly and for more than I paid (fortunately). I began my search for a BC right then and wound up finding the BC I dive today...7 years and 400 dives later.
I'm one of the folks who has tried a BP/W and didn't like it at all, so won't even consider going that direction. However, had I listened to everyone around here who love it and bought before I tried, I would have wasted my money and time. Unfortunately I learned this the hard way with my first BC, a jacket type. I bought it based on the recommendations of other divers and within 4 dives knew I had made a terrible mistake. Thankfully I had purchased it used and back to ebay it went where it sold quickly and for more than I paid (fortunately). I began my search for a BC right then and wound up finding the BC I dive today...7 years and 400 dives later.