Murphy's Law

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

stormy48

New
Messages
2
Reaction score
1
Location
N.J.
# of dives
0 - 24
I wanted to dive since I was a child, so when I finally got the chance I was thrilled. I took the long way, a series of class and pool sessions lasting 8 weeks. I went to Florida for my check out dives. My equipment was brand new, I had used it in the pool once. I got on the boat and did not have a dive buddy, so they LET me tag along with the other divers and the DM would check out my skills. I felt a bit uncomfortable at this but went along with it. We went off Key West, got in the water, oh this is great I thought. The other divers and the DM quickly disappeared as I stopped to watch a fish by a sea fan. Thinking they couldn't be far I looked for them to no avail.
After 10 min I thought I better go back to the boat. When I reached the boat I was promptly reprimanded and told to get back down there and find your group. I did as I was told but spent the next 20 min trying to find them, it was now 5 min before we were to report back to the boat. I got there first and again was told I should be with my group and was a few minutes early. I was not permitted to board the boat until the rest of the divers returned. At this point I was seriously thinking of forgetting about the next dive. We got to the next dive site and I made sure to hang by the DM. He put me through the paces and all was fine until I had to inflate the BC manually underwater. He disconnected the inflator hose, and did not reattach it. I signaled it to him and he wrote on his slate to leave it off. The rest of the dive was ok until he disappeared. I surfaced to see where the boat was and the weather had changed, the water was very choppy. I tried to inflate the BC manually but every time I put the mouthpiece up to my mouth I swallowed water and could not inflate it. The boat was a speck on the horizon. I aimed my compass at it and tried to surface swim to it but the waves were too high and I couldn't stay afloat. I blew my whistle, waved and gave the diver in distress signal but I was too far away.
I was calm until this point, when I could not catch my breath between waves I panicked. Luckily another dive boat was near and saw what was going on. Two divers swam over to me and ditched my weights and held me up till someone from my boat came on a DPV to get me. Again I was yelled at for not staying with the group and was told I would be charged for the ditched weights. Lesson learned...if it don't feel right, don't do it.
I spent the rest of my vacation in a hotel room sick as a dog. The water I swallowed was full of raw sewage.
When the Doctor heard where I was diving he called the dive shop and informed them of the water problem which was well known by the Key West diving community. They took us out there against health dept. advice.
 
A lot of this account sounds bizarre. You surfaced and were told to descend alone and find the group??? I don't think a DM would ever tell a certified diver to do that, much less a student...

The boat was a speck on the horizon? Hyperbole I hope...

It's been a while but I also don't remember having my inflator hose disconnected and having to manually inflate my BC at depth...
 
This is an incredibly bad report of a dive operation.

If your certification is through PADI, know that DM's cannot certify divers for 'checkout' dives. Many points in your story point to a serious deficiency in safety standards by the operator.
 
Most of the op's post sounds like a dream he had after the celebratory beers immediately following receipt of his certification. If any of the diving portion has any reality to it at all, then my suspicion is the op mispercieved and/or misunderstood.
 
I believe she's recalling a rather traumatic experience that took place a long time ago, and some of the details (DM vs Instructor, for example) may be a bit foggy to her. According to stormy's profile, she has been certified for over ten years, and yet this story recounts her certification dives. As well, in her profile she says her gear, described in her story as being all brand-new at the time of the events, has been used only once.

Stormy, may I ask about your motivation for posting this story? Were you so troubled by your certification dives that despite having dreamt of becoming a diver since childhood you were put off from using that brand new gear and those brand new skills for the past ten years and you'd like to get back into it? Do you hope for the support and understanding of a community of divers here to help you get your groove back? Clearly, after ten years, you can't be thinking of "outing" the dive operator or the instructor involved.....
 
I can't by the op's story. Sorry. Either time has eroded her memory so much that the story has become unrelated to reality, or it is an effort to create a conversation that pouts me in mind of a client who told me about his dive trip to the Bahamas on which they dove regularly to depths of 600 feet! He had, of course, never been diving had no idea of the limitations of our sport. I have never seen or heard of an instructor disconnecting a low pressure inflator hose, nor a student on an open water certification dive being so loosely supervised that they "got lost" watching fish. Stormy 48, what is the real story?
DivemasterDennis
 
I have no problem believing the story. I think on this very forum there was a write up about instructors in California behaving badly resulting in the injury of a writers girlfriend. As unbelievable as that story was, we all took it as fact. Why not accept this entry as a viable post?
 
I believe she's recalling a rather traumatic experience that took place a long time ago, and some of the details (DM vs Instructor, for example) may be a bit foggy to her. According to stormy's profile, she has been certified for over ten years, and yet this story recounts her certification dives. As well, in her profile she says her gear, described in her story as being all brand-new at the time of the events, has been used only once.

Stormy, may I ask about your motivation for posting this story? Were you so troubled by your certification dives that despite having dreamt of becoming a diver since childhood you were put off from using that brand new gear and those brand new skills for the past ten years and you'd like to get back into it? Do you hope for the support and understanding of a community of divers here to help you get your groove back? Clearly, after ten years, you can't be thinking of "outing" the dive operator or the instructor involved.....

You will notice I did not mention the dive operator's name. What I am telling you is true, although it does sound a bit off, it is what happened. After recouping from that fiasco, I was afraid to even get back in the water, let alone another dive. Realizing one bad experience doesn't necessarily mean another, we stopped at another dive shop on Key largo 2 days before returning home. My husband told the instructor what had happened and he spoke with me about it. I did complete my dives with that instructor and the following year I returned to do a few adventure dives. I did not however use my own gear, I rented it there because the airline charges for extra baggage, it was just easier. I did not return to diving after that due to health reasons.
As far as "outing the dive operator or the instructor" goes, no but I will tell you not to go there if you ask.
It was a well known operator. I posted it so other people might learn something from that inner voice that says
don't go, cause I didn't listen.
 
I have no problem believing the story. I think on this very forum there was a write up about instructors in California behaving badly resulting in the injury of a writers girlfriend. As unbelievable as that story was, we all took it as fact. Why not accept this entry as a viable post?

We all did NOT take it as fact. If we are talking about the same story, that was a very one sided exaggerated story and in my opinion the student's fault (and that of her boyfriend), not the instructor's.

I don't believe much of this post and I'm sure the dive op would have a very different, maybe more plausible, account of events.
 

Back
Top Bottom