jonhall
Contributor
Wish I could compare islands but have only been to one - Grand Bahama. Slow pace and low key describes it, but probably describes all of the islands.What we like is doing a vrbo or similar on the water, doing some cooking, doing some eating out, and just exploring and enjoying a slow pace for a low key trip.
This is my take from when I was there 3 ½ years ago (going back in the spring.) The island is flat and susceptible to hurricane damage - some places seemed to still be in a little disrepair, like the International Bazaar.
The normal land and water activities/excursions are available, but didn't seem to be as abundant as on some other Caribbean islands. There are a few beach clubs and a weekly beach party/cookout on Taino Beach. We frequented the Port Lucaya Marketplace quite a bit - shopping and several very good restaurants, and occasionally entertainment. There are a few sights to see around the island.
In the Freeport area there are several dive ops. There are quite a few dive sites in this area, so depending on how many days one dives, there are enough different sites that repeats are unlikely. Shark Junction, which was featured this year in a Shark Week show, is one of the sites, but reef sharks are likely to be seen at many other sites. Tiger Beach is on the northwest end of the island - I don't think most of the ops go there because of the distance.
Not a retirement location but I think one can take it for a few weeks once in a while!