Only one trip to Bon for us, but I am an OCD researcher and we really loved our week there -
All of this is IMHO so take it at face value - From the outside, the Plaza isn't in the most convenient location for town or our preferred dive sites. It's HUGE and seemed like you could do a lot of walking with gear if you're inclined to use the truck and dive all over the island (you REALLY SHOULD the variety of sites is amazing)! Also, choosing a dive op that has multiple tank pick up/drop locations to the north and south is really cool (don't know if Plaza has this). We used both Dive Friends and Wannadive and loved being able to get to fresh tanks easily regardless of where or when we were at. We LOVED the reefs in the Buddy Dive/Captain Don's area and would likely use one of those two options in the future - As someone else noted, I think you can get a 'nearly AI' option at these places. We really liked Oil Slick Leap as a site, and the Caribbean Club property looked nice, but it is secluded to the north and the road is dark at night so even if you can get an AI style option, I would not choose to stay that far out of the action. We were NOT knocked out by the dives in the 18 Palms area, but again that is just personal preference.
We did boat dives to Klein and the sites north that you can't do from shore (Rappel, and Bon Bini na Kas) and thought they were ALL great. Forest on Klein was a fav for sure! 11 boat dives seems like a lot to me - but if
easy is more important than
cover as much ground as possible,, that might be great!
We had the face plate stolen off our radio the second night in Bonaire, and Caribe truck rental did not charge us and were very accommodating about it. We DID have the CDW insurance and were glad we had it - we didn't have any other trouble, but we saw others that had lost keys, trucks stuck in sand, flat tires etc that I'm sure would have been bigger deals without coverage?? Don't know, maybe that's just for accidents. We had a friend involved in a collision (fender bender) and they put him in the 'inspector's' van and asked questions as if he'd killed someone, so if there is an accident and anyone wants to make a big deal of it, I'm sure you would really want to have the insurance. This may be a rare occurrence, I don't have enough experience to know.
This site
Bonaire Panoramas - Bonaire Map is really cool and gives you a fairly nice idea of what things look like. I did not buy a book, and just used all the info on line to plan the dives. Also, the truck rental place gave us a great map with dive sites and descriptions that we used. I did drop $5 on this kindle book and it was fine, but not all that much 'unique' information.
Amazon.com: Diving Bonaire eBook: George Lewbel: Kindle Store
If you want to shoot lion fish, go with Bas
BAS Diving to the east side and have an adventure! He's awesome and so is the diving over there! I don't know if you need to take a class to be able to shoot, but he does a LOT of hunting.
Have fun!!!!