DIR-Atlanta
Contributor
DIR teaches the concept of "minimum gas". This is the point where you must call the dive and make for the surface, because you no longer have sufficient reserves to continue. Depending on where the failure occurs on an OW dive (and how your gas was planned to begin with), you may have some extra time to play with, which is where the option of swimming can be considered.shadragon:As dictated by the training I received, if you have a low or out of air situation you call the dive immediately as you no longer have an alternative air source and make a safe ascent.
Actually, a pony bottle isn't really DIR. Cobb's Law applies - "if you think you need a pony bottle, then what you really need is doubles". The DIR approach to this situation is to plan and manage the gas appropriately. On an OW dive at recreational depths, your buddy is your backup, and there's not too much that can go wrong that will require any additional gas beyond what the two of you carry in your single tanks, provided you plan your gas reserves properly, and stick to the plan.shadragon:Today I have an HP steel tank with separate 40 cf Pony which certainly gives me a lot more gas and flexibility.
Using a pony as a bailout tends to introduce more problems than it solves, which is why we don't recommend it for DIR diving.