mizzia
Guest
I just cant choose between the mares abyss/proton xl or apeks 100/200. u probabably all are fed up talking bout the two but i just cant help it. im lost.
help me choose between the these
- Thread starter mizzia
- Start date
Please register or login
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
- Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
- A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
- You can make this box go away
I've been doing some research on regs as I've been looking to get something new. I had a look at the Mares Abyss and have spoken to a number of people about it and am quite impressed with it. Sounds like a great reg for cold water diving, if you ever plan on doing any, and the price seems reasonable. I've only read a little about the Apeks 100, so I don't know too much about it, but it also sounds like a decent reg, but a little more expensive.
Ari
Moderator
Both the Apeks and the Mares are very good regs. You will probably here more views toward the Apeks in this board.
I myself use Mares. If you do decide to go with mares, I would recomend the newer proton, based on the very good abyss but with a smaller, lighter second stage.
Ari
I myself use Mares. If you do decide to go with mares, I would recomend the newer proton, based on the very good abyss but with a smaller, lighter second stage.
Ari
cstreu1026
Contributor
I have never tried the Mares, but I was not all that impressed with ATX100 I tired. It didn't breath bad at all, it just wasn't as smooth as I was looking for.
Aquamaniac
Contributor
- Messages
- 1,257
- Reaction score
- 5
Apeks, Simplicity and Rigidity in an economical package.
There are a number of Mares "Proton" regs, but the one you want to look at is probably the V32 Proton XL. Looks like it's around $50 over the Abyss. Here's a description I pulled off an online site.... sounds pretty good.
Description
FIRST STAGE
The Proton XL is equipped with the brand new V32 first stage, which immediately sets it apart with its distinctive aesthetics and exceptional light weight for a first stage of this class. Diaphragm operation and DFC system. The forged brass body with chrome and nickel plated finish is protected by a shockproof and scratch-resistant coating. The high pressure valve features the SCS spherical seal system, for superior durability. The high and low pressure ports are positioned for optimal hose routing and maximum diving comfort.
SECOND STAGE
Top-level performance for one of the most compact second stages on the market. Proton XL is a technological powerhouse. Integrated VAD system for effortless natural breathing. Two-component second stage body construction, which offers exceptionally light weight, (just 182 grams) as well as a unique look and superior resistance to abrasion. Anodized aluminum inserts enhance the front coverplate, incorporating the "mesh-grid" system.
The exhaust valve can be easily inspected or replaced through a special opening in the exhaust ports. The first stage hose is of the "super soft" type for maximum diver comfort. The brand new mouthpiece has been designed to ensure a secure grip with minimal jaw fatigue.
Description
FIRST STAGE
The Proton XL is equipped with the brand new V32 first stage, which immediately sets it apart with its distinctive aesthetics and exceptional light weight for a first stage of this class. Diaphragm operation and DFC system. The forged brass body with chrome and nickel plated finish is protected by a shockproof and scratch-resistant coating. The high pressure valve features the SCS spherical seal system, for superior durability. The high and low pressure ports are positioned for optimal hose routing and maximum diving comfort.
SECOND STAGE
Top-level performance for one of the most compact second stages on the market. Proton XL is a technological powerhouse. Integrated VAD system for effortless natural breathing. Two-component second stage body construction, which offers exceptionally light weight, (just 182 grams) as well as a unique look and superior resistance to abrasion. Anodized aluminum inserts enhance the front coverplate, incorporating the "mesh-grid" system.
The exhaust valve can be easily inspected or replaced through a special opening in the exhaust ports. The first stage hose is of the "super soft" type for maximum diver comfort. The brand new mouthpiece has been designed to ensure a secure grip with minimal jaw fatigue.
wasnt impressed. Was almost like breathing off of a Sherwood at 100 ft. It makes noise, not a real high performance reg.
I love my Apeks, and they kick the crap out of the Proton.
Now, the Abyss is a different story. The Abyss (and the Proton Ice for that matter) can "compete" with the Apeks.
I think it is heresy to compare the Proton V32 with the Apeks ATX-200. There is no comparison. Apeks ATX-200 blows it out of the water...
Hey, cool, this is my 200th post!!!!
WOOOOOOHOOOOOOO!!!!!
<< EDITED BACK IN EDITED POLITICAL CONTENT >>
I love my Apeks, and they kick the crap out of the Proton.
Now, the Abyss is a different story. The Abyss (and the Proton Ice for that matter) can "compete" with the Apeks.
I think it is heresy to compare the Proton V32 with the Apeks ATX-200. There is no comparison. Apeks ATX-200 blows it out of the water...
Hey, cool, this is my 200th post!!!!
WOOOOOOHOOOOOOO!!!!!
<< EDITED BACK IN EDITED POLITICAL CONTENT >>
So what are the major differences between the Abyss and the Proton V32? The Abyss is definitely in the runnings, but I haven't made any decisions ... yet.
Similar threads
