Headed to Palau

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Wade,

Thanks for the report. Most of my dive experience is in Cozumel. If it is any better than that, I can't wait.

dnhill
 
Yes, it is much better than Coz. I just got back from a month in Micronesia, 15 days in Palau. Spectacular. We were on the Eclipse, a private live aboard for 12 days. Where are you staying dnhill?
 
Thanks for the trip report. What made Fiji seem better to you?
 
Thanks for the honest review of your trip. My husband and I are fairly new divers--just a couple of long weekend dive trips in Malaysia and a four day liveaboard in the Similans. With that info, any specific advice? Which of the dives were the most advanced dives? Which were the least? Also, where did you get your best information for what time of year to go, etc. Any other advice? Ginamarina :) P.S. Did you post a review of your Fiji trip? My husband has sabbatical soon and we are still deciding what to do.
 
First off, I just want to acknowledge that this is pretty subjective and one diver's best-dive-ever is another's if-I-ever-get-my-hands-on-that-travel-agent... eyebrow. Also, there may be circumstantial (sp?) differences; for example, I happened to see bull sharks in Fiji but I could have seen (but didn't) tiger sharks in Palau.

In Fiji, I saw a more diverse array of fish and they were, to some degree, fish that got me more excited. I saw more nudibranchs (and a better variety), blue ribbon eels, prettier coral, lionfish, lots of various types of shrimp, and an octopus. I did see some sharks in Fiji (including some bulls) and a wreck so I, at least, addressed some of those interests. When I was there, the vis was better in Fiji (August) than it was in Palau (December). There was also more variation of dive type in Fiji (some drift, some wreck, some concentrating on small but densely packed bommies) than in Palau (almost exclusively drift -- I admit that I could have taken a more active role directing this but I tend to trust divemasters regarding a region's best dives). Additionally, at Beqa Lagoon, there was unlimited free shore diving. On top of all this, the food and Beqa Lagoon was better than what we found in Palau. Finally, we were able to get a 10 hour direct flight from LA for around $900 versus the 24 hour, 4-hop, $1700 flights to Palau (the cost difference is probably at least somewhat due to when we went to both places).

In favor of Palau, however, there were sharks on every dive (and sometimes, quite a few), better drift dives, turtles, better (WWII !) wrecks, and more beautiful views top-side. We also saw some interesting behaviours like a bulldozer shrimp and his companion goby.

I guess my point is not the Palau was bad (it was really cool); it's just that, for my family and me, Fiji was just that much better.
 
ginamarina:
My husband and I are fairly new divers--just a couple of long weekend dive trips in Malaysia and a four day liveaboard in the Similans. With that info, any specific advice?

Just to take things in stages -- challenge one skill at a time. There are lots of great dives that fit this description. Save the more challenging dives for later.

Which of the dives were the most advanced dives? Which were the least?

Unfortunately, the best dives in Palau (i.e., the ones you go to Palau to experience) are, I think, the most advanced dives.

By far, the most advanced dives were at Peleliu -- there were updrafts and downdrafts and getting separated from the group meant the real possibility of being blown out to the open ocean. Also, with 4 foot swells, getting into the boat could be a challenge. The thing is, these were my favorite dives because we saw 15 or more sharks in a giant school and other big animals.

Siaes tunnel represents an overhead environment at depth. These, individually, can be tricky but, together, represents a substantial opportunity for error. My computer is pretty conservative so I only had 8 minutes of bottom time by the time I got the first tunnel opening -- I chose not to enter.

Chandelier cave is also an overhead environment that includes some tight spaces and darkness. I know some very good divers that had to abort that dive in the middle because it made them feel very uncomfortable.

Many dives in Palau represent skills beyond those that come from an openwater certification. There were many wall dives -- if you don't have good control of your buoyancy, this can mean going a lot deeper than you intended. Lots of the dives are deep and this requires paying close attention to your bottom time and your air consumption. Several of the dives are drift dives and this can mess with your buoyancy -- particularly when the current is ripping. If you go through your air pretty quickly, you'll have to surface before the rest of the group and subject yourself to the possibility of being separated from the group by the current or bouncing off some of the copious boat traffic in the area.

As for easier dives, the Jake seaplane was dead easy. Also, German Channel was a straight-forward dive (and provides the opportunity to see Mantas). Jellyfish lake was a simple snorkle and a must-do.

Also, where did you get your best information for what time of year to go, etc.

A lot of this information came from Undercurrent (www.undercurrent.org) magazine and their yearly chapbooks. Other info came from discussing trips with other divers (e.g., at the Long Beach scuba show and here, on scubaboard).

My wife also planned around the moon phases. The least current is found when the moon is half-full. The swiftest currents happen during a full moon (the currents tend to be a little less during a new moon).

Did you post a review of your Fiji trip?

No, I didn't (but my wife posted a trip report to undercurrent and subscribers can get access to this info via their online chapbooks). We went to the Beqa Lagoon Resort at the recommendation of Joe Liburdi (he owns a local dive shop) and we loved it -- the diving was pretty easy and there were lots of beautiful fish. After that, we went to Wananavu (sp?) resort and dived with Kai Viti divers. That diving was more challenging but gave us the opportunity to see bigger animals and more interesting drift/wall dives (like High-8). The food was great at Beqa and the water was absolutely drinkable while the meals were just okay at Wananavu. You can find underwater pix of our trip at http://travel.adventure101.com/fiji. We don't have our Palau pix up yet (and there aren't as many of them -- our photographer was out much of the time with an ear infection).

If you have any other questions, feel free to contact me (wade@adventure101.com).
 
WadeGuthrie:
Also, there may be circumstantial (sp?) differences; for example, I happened to see bull sharks in Fiji but I could have seen (but didn't) tiger sharks in Palau.

.


Nice report Wade.

But just one small nitpick. I worked in Palau for 3 years and have about 1500 dives there. I never saw a Tiger Shark, it sounds like you are holding that against Palau for some reason. Tigers are much more reliable at Beqa Lagoon in Fiji...
 
I mentioned tiger sharks because our divemaster said that he has seen some. I like the bigger sharks so I meant to say that I would have enjoyed seeing a tiger shark but that it was just a matter of (bad) luck that I didn't. I didn't want to hold it against Palau that I didn't see a big shark that I _could_ have seen.

Our divemaster also said that there are 3 resident bull sharks at Blue Corner (and I believe, based on fin position, that I saw one -- but maybe it was just wishful thinking). Did you ever see a bull shark in Palau?
 
Here is a picture to give you an idea what Blue Corner is like on a light current morning. Check the bubbles and the angle of my reef hook rope.
 
Nope, never saw a Bull either. Although there is/was a resident at Peleliu Corner when i was there, usually saw it in the blue after getting blown into open ocean for safety stop. For some reason never saw it.....grrrrrrrrr

Did see a few Tigers from the surface, just never underwater although a few people i worked with did.
 

Back
Top Bottom