35 companies to choose from - all are excellent - all don't offer the same experience.
Sunset & Cracked Conch - shore dives. Sunset is also a resort. If you want to do boat ops...
- do you want to dive with a group? ie, cattle boat
big boat with a toilet
follow the leader UW
you don't choose where, the op decides where the dives will occur based on X Y Z . . .
- do you want a small boat experience, tiny group or your own personal guide?
- allowing you to choose where you want to go?
- allowing you to have your own profile?
Solution: Cayman Turtle Divers
Our afternoon dives, it was just us two + DM + captain. So we basically had custom + private for no extra charge.
If one or two more couples, you decide together if you want Deep + Shallow, or Shallow + Shallow (ie, wrecks or walls)
FWIW, every diver I met there, told me that diving the East or off of Rum Point the dive quality was much better than along Seven Mile Beach.
I did one shore dive from the Cracked Conch, didn't see turtles but saw signs. I recommend for a evening dive, as the wall there has bio luminescent plankton, like the lagoons in Eastern Porto Rico.
Sunset house doesn't have a beach, Rum Point area has a beautiful beach.
Shop around & have fun!
Edit - Diving in Maui, Hawaii & Mexico Cozumel area, saw turtles on every single dive, sometimes 3 or 4.
In Grand Cayman, not a single view in the wild.
I expected "more".