This is probably a wrong thought, but thinsulate is thinsulate regardless of whom sews it into a suit. Sure you have different types, but I believe for the most part one will find them similar.
I guarantee thinsulate will keep you warm if the drysuit floods, at least my Viking Thinsulate kept me warm when the Dui drysuit I did during the demo days flooded, I honestly didn't know it had flooded as bad as it did. I knew it leaked a bit, but I was soaked and was warm.
For what it's worth I have a buddy who dives the Bare suit we're talking about and he's told me he gets a little cold in it. I've never got cold when I use my thinsulate undergarment, I've been cool in the fleece stuff however but not cold.
I'd say it all depends on how a person reacts to cool temps as to what they must use as an undergarment. Fit is very important however. I have tried on the undergarment we're talking about and I thought it would keep me warm based on how it felt to me in the store.
Thinsulate does wear out however. Washing it is pretty hard on it and will cause it's demise sooner rather than later, so don't wash them too often.