Here is the update:
I went to Utila and dove with Utila Dive Center. I did my AOW (piece of cake) and my Rescue (more challenging, fun, great course, highly recommend it). I was very tempted to stay and do my divemaster there as well. Would have been another 4 weeks or so.
Utila is great by the way, especially if you are single and in the 20-35 age group or you can fake it

Lots of young backpackers going through there. Lots of partying. Had a blast.
Wasn't awed by the diving on Utila, although it was decent. Warm water, good visibility, saw some cool things, but overall didn't have the marine life I was hoping for. So wasn't sure i wanted to do another 4 weeks there - I felt I had seen it all - although I was very tempted by the camraderie and the social life. I definitely see how people end up getting "stuck' there.
I dove Roatan for a week afterwards, checking it out for possibly doing my DM there. The diving was good, slightly better. More variety and a bit more marine life. (The shark dive called cara de cara was awesome!) West End is definitely more touristy and a bit more expensive than Utila but it was slow season. Most of the shops wanted 6 weeks minimum for DM.
So:
*Already dove Utila and felt I had seen it
*Didn't want to do 6 more weeks on Roatan during the slow season
*Didn't want to spend a chunk of cash on a dive computer
*Knew that if I really wanted to work in the industry I would still have to take another course
*Decided to take the time and money to just travel Central America and dive instead. That's what I am doing now.
FYI, dives in the Bay islands were cheap. 2 tank on Utila for $55 and on Roatan for $70. I am finding dives elsewhere to be a bit more expensive, often around $100 and frequently more depending on the size of the boat and how far it has to travel to get to the dive sites, for example, the Belize dives to the outer reefs.
Thanks for all the input everybody.