What I really like about this post is that no opinion is dogmatically represented here.
A short story that happened to me during a too long and deep freedive.
When I realized that I probably wouldn't make it to the surface I dropped my weight belt.
Then it went black and the first thing when I regained consciousness was lying high on the surface breathing heavily through my snorkel.
Without the snorkel with my face in the water I could have drowned.
That may be the case most of the time, but with myself I have the impression that the conscious mind slowly withdraws and unconscious behavior makes room.
I have blown out the snorkel over a thousand times, and I registered that I was at the surface by tilting into the horizontal position. If you drop the weight belt it happens by itself.
Keeping the snorkel in your mouth, blowing it out at the right time and surviving for a short time without conscious thought is possible. As a freediver you practise this all the time at a lesser extent, which saves a lot of oxygen.
The diving described by dcvf page 1 # 8 is much safer, but who will give up freediving if he has no buddy or float on the surface to grab ?