I agree with Hintermann. Hard to beat LCBR at the price point.
Southern Cross is a little more posh but also higher priced. In my opinion, not worth the differential.
LCBR has recently redecorated rooms, great valet dive op good food and an OK pool area.
If you want to splurge, the oceanfront rooms are essentially right on the beach, have nice patios and are equipped with a fridge and microwave.
The standard rooms are lovely but do not have the view or private patio.
We have stayed at LCBR a number of times and like it better than any other place we have tried in the region including Coz, Roatan, Grand Cayman, the Brac, Utila, Bonaire, and Grand Turk. We like all of these places but just like LCBR better. From the time the plane lands to the time you get back aboard, you are catered to.
We keep going back as often as we can swing it.
I would not recommend a condo on LC as there are no real grocery stores and few restaurant options.
I think that LCBR will do a package with condo accommodation, meals at LCBR and meals but it makes more sense to me and is more economical just to stay in an oceanfront room at LCBR.