Jsh:
My wife have changed our plans and are now planning a 10 day trip to Cozumel. Dec 25-Jan 4'ish. We will be making all our own arrangements. I am looking for some recommendations for a dive shop with rooms for rent that will give us a good deal on a package, we are not looking of anything fancy, and the quieter, the further away from the crowds, the better. Hopefully a place with a beach, or a really close beach.
The only place I've got a recommendation for so far is Papa Hogs, I hear they are run by Canadians (which I am) and have small boats and are very flexible on where you go.
Also, we can save a bunch of money if we fly into Cancun and make our own way to Cozumel, anyone done that before? is it worth the extra $300 to fly direct?
Thanks
Jsh
Over the past two years my wife and I have also done the same time frame. It really is worth it to fly into Cozumel. If you fly into Cancun, you will have to make it through the taxi crowd and find a deal on a taxi to the ferry at Playa Del Carmen. I have heard it is possible to get for $30, but you have to haggle. The ferry is $9 per person one way. Then you will need to get a taxi to your hotel. As you leave, you have to do the whole process in reverse. So, the basic question you want to ask yourself is how much hassle you want to put up with in getting to your hotel.
As for ops, there are a whole bunch of great ones out there. One of the problems in recommending one op over the other is that people have different experiences. I would say that there are really no bad ops on Cozumel.
However, we dove with Papa Hogs and had an excellent time. They have small boats and a great staff. Mike was a bit of a pain to deal with, but his wife is wonderful. They used to have accommodations to rent, but that was pre-Wilma. I am not sure what they have now.
Other dive ops that come highly recommended are Blue XT Sea, Deep Blue (we usally go with them), and Dive with Martin. Do a search and you will find great things about all of them.
Caribe Blue is an excellent choice for hotels and they have a great dive shop on the premises. They are a bit of a walk from downtown, if that is an issue. Another good choice is Casa Mexicana, they are centraly located and provide a nice big breakfast every morning, which is nice on December 25th, when everything else is closed.
You will have a great time regardless.