catbrown:
If someone tells me they got their DM n Thailand or Honduras, they immediately step backin the queue
Well, can't really speak for Koh Tao, though I have been there and have been living in Thailand for 5 years...BUT...
I did my DM course in Honduras with Utila Dive Centre in 1996. A lot of the dive centres there 8 years ago were pretty basic, and in the last few years the same dive centre has become an IDC centre and does all kinds of tech diving..but I digress..My DM training there was top notch, I took 6 weeks on the course, must have assisted on 15 courses, did about 80 dives during the course, the instructors were dedicated, we had good theory classes, and the instructors were very good at putting the DMT's in a leadership position (while they watched closely), such as giving briefings, leading dives, helping students with gear etc... I went back in 1998 for some DM work (unpaid) and later did my IDC there. I saw a helluva lot of good Dm's, especially in terms of people management, being friendly, helpful in and out of the water and being able to organise groups of divers. One of the advantages of doing a DM course in a place like Utila or Koh Tao is that you get a lot of experience, not just doing the theory and helping with the minimum recommended courses to complete the DM course.
OOh, cat you got me going now...
The only thing I may agree about your point is that training in Koh Tao or Utila, which is mainly a young persons, backpacking world, does not help you to deal with "resort" customers, it's a different world. I saw it myself as I did a little work in the Utila Lodge resort as well as working for the more backpacker oriented dives schools. The resort was full on service, esp. with the mainly US clientele - the DM has to be there all the time and have the answer to everything, and be prepared to talk diving all day and all night. The backpackers are there for a good time. I'd meet my students at the bar and have a few rum 'n' cokes and talk about traveling.
Lack of skills for a resort is nothing to do with training in Koh Tao or Utila, its a lack of expereince with that kind of customer. So in fact you may be justified not to employ a Thai or Honduras trained DM, but it is NOT for lack of good training. I think there was a kind of dirty rumour floating round about these places some years back and I tell you, the dive centres in Utila were very aware of it and so went out of their way to give better training, even if it was for a cheap price. I'm sure the same is true in Koh Tao. There is maybe a misconception that you get a kind of hippy druggie instructor who's been out in the sun too long and teaches very lazily. I think the opposit is true. The instructors I had in Utila, and hopefully I was the same when I became one, were professional and hard working, and gave a lot of time for their DM students.
And that's all I have to say about that...