Considerations for new divers and those who dive with them?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

pasley

Contributor
Scuba Instructor
Messages
3,184
Reaction score
283
Location
Lakewood, CA
# of dives
1000 - 2499
Recently, I was at a dive site and another group of divers arrived. In their ranks was a new diver, as in “first dive since being certified” new.

The dive site was at the bottom of a cliff requiring a walk of about 2 city blocks in full dive gear down a steep road, then trail to get to. The entry was off rocks (boulders) with a pleasant dive along a reef system and exiting 300 yards away against a strong current. The exit site is a beach made of large “pebbles” the size of baked potatoes to soccer balls and bigger which is ok, but not as good as a sand beach for a new diver.

This site was IMHO, the wrong site for a new diver. The dive itself was easy enough, 40-65 feet depth. But due to the long hike to the site, the diver was exhausted before he even reached the water. Long story short, the current was strong and the diver wound up back on the rocks, too tired to do much more than sit upon the rocks just in the water. Kayaks had tried to tow the diver into the beach, but were unable to make any progress against the strong current and he was unable to assist by kicking. The situation required a hike in of 1 city block over boulders to reach the diver who after a 30 minute rest was able to walk out, while someone else carried his equipment.

So that brings us to the question of the day. What are the items a new diver should consider when going to dive and selecting a dive site?

I am not an expert, but here is my list to start the discussion going:
1. Do NOT blindly accept that a dive site is within your capabilities to dive just because your more experienced (even if he is a Dive Master) buddy thinks it will be OK. Make your own evaluations and be honest with yourself.
2. If you think or say, “do you think we should?”. Don’t, go home and dive another day.
3. What is your current level of physical conditioning? You will be wearing a rubber suit and carrying 70 pounds or more of gear to get to the dive site. SCUBA diving is physically demanding. If you are not in good shape, start with easy short walk access sites.
4. How far a walk from the car to the water is it? Are the hills involved (most likely)
5. How strong are the currents?
6. How deep is the dive site?
7. How far is the in water swim to the dive site?
8. Availability of exit points or bail out locations. The above site had only two viable choices, a bolder exit at the entry site (not good for a new diver) or the 300 yard away smaller rock beach (he was too tired to get there).
8. Waves – how big and where are they breaking? Waves over 1-2 feet, not the place for you until you get more experience with the small waves. Breaking far off shore, reconsider. Over 4 feet, none of us really need to dive it, the visibility will be garbage anyway.
9. What is the reported visibility. 10 feet should be the absolute minimum for a new diver. Los visibility increases your chances of getting separated dramatically. That leaves the novice diver in a solo situation and hard to find.
10. The experience of the other divers. DO NOT BLINDLY TRUST. But I mention it here only to say, is you only dive partner also a new diver. Are the blind leading the blind? You should dive with someone who has at least 20 dives in the past 12 months (more is better) if you can. But again, don’t blindly trust them, they may be idiots. Use your common sense, if it feels or sounds unsafe, it is!
11. What is the topography of the entry and exit points like? Sand beach (good) small rocks (ok maybe) or a true rocky entry between boulders or off a solid large rock monolith?
 
pasley:
So that brings us to the question of the day. What are the items a new diver should consider when going to dive and selecting a dive site?

I am not an expert, but here is my list to start the discussion going:...


12. Remember, shore diving blows

13. Save the boulder-hopping for mountain goats, and skip sites requiring an unreasonable DCS-exacerbating post dive hill climb with associated schlep in full gear and exposure suit (insert most OCal dive sites here) and pick a mellower dive site. Better yet, eBay the gameboy and call Cat Express go to the park and drill while you mull over a better place to dive, or get on a local dive boat and actually have a nice dive. :eyebrow:

You're 100% right - you got to know your limitations, pick wiser "friends" and consider all requirements associated with the dive (like getting in and out!) and not just the dive its self.

That's good stuff, Mel.

---
Ken
 
pasley:
This site was IMHO, the wrong site for a new diver. The dive itself was easy enough, 40-65 feet depth. But due to the long hike to the site, the diver was exhausted before he even reached the water. Long story short, the current was strong and the diver wound up back on the rocks, too tired to do much more than sit upon the rocks just in the water.
. . . .
3. What is your current level of physical conditioning? You will be wearing a rubber suit and carrying 70 pounds or more of gear to get to the dive site. SCUBA diving is physically demanding. If you are not in good shape, start with easy short walk access sites.

I think those are all important considerations, but it seems to me the particular problem in the story as you describe it turns mostly on point no. 3 (and then maybe the strength of the current).

Whether a person is a new diver or experienced, you can't go diving in a place where you can't handle the hike to the water. I remember more than 20 years ago being asked to go dive in the lake in the crater of Popocatepetl (a volcano in Mexico), to see what we could see. In the end, none of us tried it. I was the most experienced diver in the group (and the least experienced climber), but I was also the only one who really doubted his ability to haul his stuff to the dive site.
 
Stirling:
I think those are all important considerations, but it seems to me the particular problem in the story as you describe it turns mostly on point no. 3 (and then maybe the strength of the current). ...
I agree, individual physical fitness ranks rigth at the top. Physically tired people make mental mistakes and it just dominos from there.
 

Back
Top Bottom