Canon S230 and Strobe

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

frankymalone

Registered
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
Location
Canada
Hi, I am new to this site and was wondering if I could get some help.
I am diving with my husband in Galapagos Islands in May and own a Canon S230 with waterproof case. This camera has been amazing for all shots taken in South East Asia and Belize etc; however, I am thinking that I may need a strobe for Galapagos.
So, I have two questions:
1. Do I need a strobe for diving in Galapagos
2. What strobe would work with the Canon S230

Thanks a ton!
 
frankymalone:
Hi, I am new to this site and was wondering if I could get some help.
I am diving with my husband in Galapagos Islands in May and own a Canon S230 with waterproof case. This camera has been amazing for all shots taken in South East Asia and Belize etc; however, I am thinking that I may need a strobe for Galapagos.
So, I have two questions:
1. Do I need a strobe for diving in Galapagos
2. What strobe would work with the Canon S230

Thanks a ton!

Well, ... if you dive at night you will need a strobe. Seriously, if you don't dive at night you should

Depth is another issue if you are diving below 35 to 40 feet the strobe will add a lot of the missing color.

The camera has abuilt in strobe that will do some of the above but the external strobe is more powerfull and has a far greater range but more importently it cam be moved away from the camera's lens and will greatly reduce backscatter.

There is a bit of a learning curve. use the strobe on local dives first the learn how to use it. The external strobe requires some manual exposure calculation. It is not just "auto mode" and you will be thinking guide numbers and f-stops. Make sure you can get a number of local dives in with the new strobe before your vacation.
 
Thanks so much for the advice. It seems like there is a lot for me to learn. F-Stops and guide numbers - WOW. It sounds pretty complicated.
I will do some reading in the meantime.

Thanks again,



ChrisA:
Well, ... if you dive at night you will need a strobe. Seriously, if you don't dive at night you should

Depth is another issue if you are diving below 35 to 40 feet the strobe will add a lot of the missing color.

The camera has abuilt in strobe that will do some of the above but the external strobe is more powerfull and has a far greater range but more importently it cam be moved away from the camera's lens and will greatly reduce backscatter.

There is a bit of a learning curve. use the strobe on local dives first the learn how to use it. The external strobe requires some manual exposure calculation. It is not just "auto mode" and you will be thinking guide numbers and f-stops. Make sure you can get a number of local dives in with the new strobe before your vacation.
 
In the Galapagos you also need to think about managing the strobe in some pretty strong currents.. I took mine with me in November but never used it, I did not know it well enough to be fully comfortable with it and the current meant I had enough to think about without adding it into the equation. Of the 16 of us I think only one was using strobe and that was with video gear.
I would say unless you have got a good opportunity to get the practice in and are comfortable in strong current just take your camera.
Alison
 
Thanks for that advice. I will definitely not invest in a strobe now given you information.
I was wondering if you could tell me more about the currents and how you dealt with them. Also, how did you like the diving in the Galapagos? What didn't you like? What boat did you take?
Sorry for all the questions, but I would love to hear about your trip.
 
Loved the diving (November 2004). Current was moderate on most ocassions and only occasionaly what I defined as strong (I am guessing between 1 and 3 knots but really I do not have much to base that on - there were time when it was difficult to even hold onto a rock and stay stationery against the current).

At Darwin and Woolf which are in far North we would backward roll of the inflatable and descend immediately (no return to the surface because that could lead to you drifitng off the spot). Once we were at about 17m we would cling to the reef with one hand (no coral so no real problem apart from barnacles - take gloves) and wait to see what came past. With one hand on the reef and one on the camera not much extra capability to move a srobe around. Also what we were photographing was oftern between 10 -15m away. Hammerheads, silky sharks, sometime turtles and heaps and heaps of jacks, reef fish etc - veritable fish soup - lots of free swimming moray eels occasional marlin, yellow trumpet fish etc. In other places lots of rays, and sealions and dolphins and pilot whales on the surface.

After 5- 15m of reef hugging (at Darwin's Arch where we spent 3.5 days) we would either strike out into the blue or drift down with the current - depth between 18 -30m. I spotted three whalesharks amazing.

The current was most problematic if you didn't descend on the right spot and needed to work back into it or if you caught a down current - these were not viciously down ward but when you are working hard to ascend and not getting anywhere you need to have the light go on in the head that says swim sideways out ot it.. At other sites it was always drift diving - occassional colourful wall but most often big stuff, rays, sealions etc.

Don't go on a standard Galapagos trip if macro is your only interest, while there is undoubtedly great macro stuff there that is not what the itinerarys are built around. I was happy spending 10 dives (3.5 days at Darwin) doing virtually the same dive looking for the same stuff - if is phenomenal.

We were on Lammerlaw, an excellent boat and crew, more luxurious than I needed but why complain. If I went again I might use Mistral which is run by same company but a bit less expensive.

Things to think about:
Woolf and Darwin - where the whalesharks are - but I suspect not in May, do some research to find out where what you want to see is likely to be - not all itinerarys include Wollf and Darwin.

For my money I would not do a trip that did not have some land visits -the wildlife on land is pretty amazing.

Cheers

Alison
 
One further thought if you don't already have it invest in software like Photoshop elements - makes a huge difference to my non strobe shots and a lot cheaper than a strobe.
 
FWIW I have never figured out the whole guide number thing...but I do understand the f stops and shutter speeds and manual control of my strobe. Don't feel you have to learn it all...get out there and have fun!
 

Back
Top Bottom