Roatanman,
I don't need much as far as between/after dive entertainment. It's all about diving & relaxing.
Yes, airfare & flight time are key issues. Assuming that I drive 4+ hours to SEA instead of flying from nearby ALW or PSC, I am looking at $1800 & 19+ hours to Bonaire or $1500 & 8.5 hours to Roatan.
The cost of diving can be quite significant as well. In Cabo we dove 2 tanks-3days and spent $650.
Adjustor,
I'll track down your review.
I think you need to see which resorts have availability. I would do CCV over FI as one is a smaller dive-only resort, the other is a family resort with diving. I have friends who have gone to FI twice because it is cheaper than CCV and both times they came back and complained about the dive boats being crowded and too many beginners. They liked the resort itself okay but say it is big.
Cozumel you can do very cheap if you don't want fancy but it is harder to get more dives in. The best dives in Coz are down south, Palancar horseshoe, bricks, and deep, Columbia deep. All the dive ops go to them. Some of the shallower great dives are closer to the city up north. If you want to go to Cozumel, get the map
Can-Do Travel Guides and then pick your hotel. Dive ops vary from okay to great and there are 50+ of them, most with only 1 small 6-pack boat. The biggest dive op is Dive Paradise and they tend to be a cattleboat op with big crowded boats. We have also heard negatives about Del Mar Aquatics for same reason. I would stay away from them. Other than that, any dive op will get you great dives. We always dive with PapaHogs but have nothing against the others. If you stay at
Cozumel Scuba Diving at Scuba Club Cozumel Dive Resort and Scuba Cozumel Dive Shop they have their own boats, all inclusive with meals and we hear nothing but raves about them. Our next trip to Coz we will stay there and dive with them. Resort seems alot like CCV.
Bonaire is fantastic and shore diving is amazing. I wouldn't go there unless you intend to dive dive dive as there isnt' much else to do. We plan to go back there again because we enjoyed it so much.
If you have the dates when you want to go, then call Caradonna and see what they can work for you. They might can get you a great deal on airfare. A couple from our Roatan boat told us about the deal they got and it made us jealous! Their airfare from NJ was half what we paid.
robin