BCD or Dry Suit?

[mstudley]

v_1matst: what BC would you then suggest so that I can get the biggest bang for my buck?

Well, all I can suggest is going to your LDS and trying them out until you find one you like. Tell them your budget and see if they will work with it.

I happen to prefer a back inflate. I currently use the Black Diamond, however I think it's too expensive and too bulky. I am in the process of moving over to a backplate and wing setup. This could be the 'most bang for your buck' because you can change wings depending on what type of diving you are doing (single, doubles, greater/lesser lift, etc) and the backplate can also be changed (steel, aluminum, weighted STAs, etc). The harness is more streamlined too. It won't have all the bells and whistles the jacket style BCs have, but it has what is needed.

Again, try everything out if you can before you buy it. This will end up saving you money in the long run.

 

[drkwing]

Thanks for the advice! The Orion is the back plate & wing set up, but you wouldn't suggest it?

 

[teknitroxdiver]

Thanks for the advice! The Orion is the back plate & wing set up, but you wouldn't suggest it?

The Orion is not a BP/W setup.

It's a back-inflate jacket.

This is a BP/W: http://extreme-exposure.com/halc/buoyancy-18spec.shtml

I would recommend the BP/W setup, it's expandable, comfortable, and more streamlined.

 

[drkwing]

Oh, I see

 

[hex92]

Buy the BC. Its only $150. Think about it......If you go buy a $1000 dry suit and have to RENT a BC everytime you dive....HOW are you SAVING any $$$$???!!! :icosm02:

 

[renpirate]

There is a real disparity in the amount of money for each item. $150 as opposed to $1000. If you already have your own wetsuit and don't get cold too easily, then buy a good BC. I suggest renting a few different types and trying them out before buying. However, if you don't have your own wet suit and you tend to get cold I would highly recommend the dry suit, it makes worlds of difference. I do most of my diving in the North West and it does get cold. Keep in mind though, if you get a dry suit there is also the issue of undergarments and larger fins.