A battery update after the last dive trip. The scavenged batteries from the laptop power supply worked totally fine.
Prior to the trip I had purchased an elcheapo china dive light (bad eBay habit). Several weeks before the trip I loaded one of the scavenged batteries into the elcheapo light to test it out. All worked well. A few days before the trip, the light did not work. The battery was dead. Seems the crappy light still drew current when it was turned off. WTF? My other lights did not do this, they had a shelf life of many (6+) months with a battery installed.
I was prepared to toss the battery as it had obviously been discharged to death. Nope - popped it into the charger and several hours later the battery was good to go. I also left one of the scavenged batteries in my charger over the weekend. It still works fine.
So far I have not experienced any reason not to use the scavenged batteries from a laptop power supply.
P.S. on the other hand, the elcheapo china light will never go underwater with me again. It cut out several times when the maximum power setting was applied. Worked fine after removing and re-installing the same battery. Just not something I can do underwater...