Trip Report Bali 2-Week Dive Safari, Oct. 2024

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

nippurmagnum

Contributor
Messages
458
Reaction score
653
Location
Washington DC metro
# of dives
500 - 999
My wife and I organized our own 2-week dive safari to Bali in Oct. 2024. This was our first trip to Bali, and we LOVED the experience. We dove Menjangan, Pemuteran, Kubu, Tulamben, Amed, Candidasa, Padang Bai, and Nusa Penida, and enjoyed them all. We had 27 dives over 10 dive days, as well as 7 non-diving days to explore the incredible island top-side, including three days in Ubud. Here’s how we did it:

HOW WE GOT THERE: We flew coach on Turkish Air from Washington Dulles to Istanbul (10 hours), and then straight from Istanbul to Bali (12 hours). We had a 10-hour layover in Istanbul, and Turkish Air offered a free city tour, but I had been to Istanbul several times and wanted to show my wife the sights myself. We had obtained a free Turkish tourist visa online two days before the tripon the official website, and clearing immigrations was fast and easy. So we stashed our hand luggage at the IST airport lockers ($12), took an Uber to the city ($40) and spent 5 hours visiting Hagia Sophia, the Blue Mosque, and Istiklal Street, with a very good dinner at my favorite Istanbul restaurant, Pera Antakya. We Ubered back to the airport, wiped out but well fed and happy. Our tickets cost $1,100 with two free suitcases, and the food and service on Turkish Air was quite good. The only obnoxious note is that Turkish charges $35 per leg for seat selection, but we checked in using their app six hours before the flight, and where assigned an aisle and middle seat together in the middle of the cabin, which was all we needed; and the airline seemed to have no problem reassigning seats at the counter if you asked nicely.

When we got to Bali, immigration was a breeze. We had obtained an Indonesian e-visa in advance from the official site, as well as a mandatory online monkeypox declaration, and being able to scan both things meant that we entered through an automated gate, and they didn’t even stamp our passport. It took less than 5 minutes. We had to wait half an hour for our luggage, but we were out of the airport in less than half an hour.

TRANSPORTATION/ACCOMODATIONS IN BALI: This was our first visit to Bali and we wanted to err on the side of being pampered, so we stayed in Airbnbs and resorts in the $125 to $200 a night price range — which in Bali meant “very nice to palatial.” Our first stop was in Ubud, where we stayed for three nights in a lovely, quiet Airbnb villa with private infinity pool and a charming free breakfast delivered to the villa every morning, for $125 a night. Villa in Kecamatan Ubud · ★4.93 · 1 bedroom · 1 bed · 1.5 baths Our other “bases” were four oceanfront resorts, which I’ll describe below.

For transportation around the island, we relied mostly on the driver that the Ubud Airbnb sent to pick us up ai the airport. He spoke good English, had a well maintained SUV, and was happy to explain the island’s culture and way of life. He charged us anywhere from $40 to $70 per day, depending on how far we went and how long he had to drive back. On the day that he charged us $70, he drove us for 8 hours, and had a four hour drive back home, for instance; needless to say, we tipped him well. We visited all the temples, rice fields, waterfalls, monkey forests, etc. that we wanted to see, with all the freedom that comes from having a knowledgeable private driver.

For local transportation in Ubud and Sanur, we used Grab, which is Indonesia’s version of Uber. Drivers were universally friendly and every single one of them asked if we needed a driver for day trips, so that would be another great way to “audition” drivers to take you around the island.

DIVING IN PEMUTERAN/MENJANGAN (3 dive days): We started our dive trip in the northwest. We picked Pemuteran as a base because we’d read that it was a quiet, traditional village with a nice beach on a secluded bay, and all of that was absolutely true. We stayed at the Taman Sari resort, which we loved, and dove with Karang Divers, their contracted shop. The owner is Portuguese, and obviously cares about the local community, from which almost all his staff come.

Karang candidly recommended that we focus our diving on Menjangan rather than the closer Pemuteran sites, and it was great advice. We spent two days diving Menjangan. We thought Menjangan had world class wall diving, with amazing soft corals, not an inch of wall without life on it, crystal visibility, and little or no current:

In particular we loved diving the westernmost dive site at Menjangan, Eel Garden, which is actually halfway between Menjangan and Java. Not just for the gorgeous walls, but also for the dramatic backdrop of the Java volcanoes when you surface.

We did two dives in Pemuteran itself. The first was a boat dive at Napoleon reef, which was a perfectly decent reef, but did not hold a candle to the Menjangan dives. The second dive was very special, though — it was a dusk/night dive to see mandarinfish mating. This is a dive that other shops don’t offer because it takes patience to wait for the mandarinfish to come out, and you really can’t do it with more than two divers. The Karang guide was phenomenal, and we saw four mating dances, You can only see the dances using red lights, as dive lights will make the mandarinfish dive for cover, but the red light made the whole thing even more mysterious.


We had read mixed reports on whether Menjangan/Pemuteran was worth the long haul, and my wife and I are both on the side of “hell, yes.”

DIVING IN TULAMBEN/AMED (4 dive days): Here I have to start with a tip of the hat to Johnnie B on Scubaboard, who recommended diving with Wonder Dive, a local shop in Tulamben. We loved those guys, they are outstanding macro guides and just fun people, the Balinese owner wears dreadlocks and Māori tattoos and that doesn’t begin to capture his zest for life.

Wonder Dive rents a couple of villas for $20 a night and we were tempted to stay with them, but instead we decided to lodge at the Siddharta resort in Kubu, a 10 minute drive away. The Siddharta was a boutique yoga-themed resort with luxurious rooms and a gorgeous infinity pool, and at $140 was well worth the splurge. The Wonder guys picked us up with their truck every morning and were absolutely flexible.

Over four days, we did 14 phenomenal dives. The macro sites are Tulamben were by far my favorite, and the Wonder guides showed us pigmy seahorses, ghost pipefish, harlequin shrimp, ribbon eels, innumerable nudis, orangutan and skeleton shrimp, larval frog fish tinier than the tip of your fingernail, and countless other macro marvels. These are just some highlights:


PA130729.jpeg




PA120381.jpeg



PA120460.jpeg


IMG_4391.jpeg

On one dive, while photographing a harlequin shrimp, I looked over to my left and caught sight of a frog fish eyeing a pipefish (actually it was a razor fish but I prefer to claim that it was a pipefish) — and I caught it on video swallowing it in the blink of an eye:


We did a night dive of the Liberty wreck, which was a circus of lights with a ridiculous number of divers in the water, but two days later dove the wreck at 3 pm, and had it to ourselves. I honestly wasn’t very impressed by the wreck, it’s very broken up and while it is covered in life, it’s all rather jumbled together. I much preferred the muck dives, and other Tulamben sites like Coral Garden and the Drop Off.

We also dove the Kubu Boga wreck, and had that to ourselves as well on a 3 pm dive. That wreck has less life on it but is much more intact than the Liberty, and in my opinion was mich more of a true wreck dive.

The Wonder guides also drove us up to Amed for a day, where we had the unexpected pleasure of running into Johnnie B from Scubaboard, who happened to be diving in the area, and thanking him in person for recommending the Wonder guides. Amed itself was well worth diving as well, though we found that the sites had significant current, of which there was virtually none at Tulamben. Topside, Amed also seemed busier than Tulamben, with quite a few tourists tooling around in mopeds, and I preferred the quieter vibes at Tulamben and Kubu. Though I will say that the views of Mount Agung from Amed are just stunning.

We thought the four days in this area was enough, but we could have stayed longer. And if I go back to Indonesia to do a Komodo liveaboard (which I’m already planning), I will likely tack on some days in Tulamben to that trip. The muck diving really was out of this world.
 
( continued)

One last image from Tulamben, of a tiny frog fish.

PA152592.jpeg


DIVING IN CANDIDASA/PADANG BAI (2 dive days)

We moved to the Candi Beach Hotel in Candidasa for our next dive base, and at $200 a night, this was the splurgiest and most luxurious place we stayed at. We had a beachfront sky suite with a spa in the balcony, which would have cost three to four times that price anywhere but Bali. We dove with the hotel’s shop, Diving Candidasa, which is German-managed.

We loved the hotel, but absolutely HATED the dive shop. In an island full of gracious, kind, and courteous people, this shop had somehow assembled a gruff, dismissive, and just plain rude staff. The dive guides were indifferent and just plain sloppy — before getting in the water, I asked one dive guide to make sure my tank was fully open, and he insisted that it was, but I realized he had closed it fully and opened it a quarter turn. He shrugged it off like it was an every day mistake. The other guide on the boat was German, had been in Bali for less than a year, and was attentive only to German divers, rolling her eyes at anyone else.

It was a shame, because the dive sites were quite interesting, though challenging, and with a better dive shop they would have been much more enjoyable. We dove out of Padangbai harbor the first day, because the seas were too rough for boats to come out of Candidasa, and the Blue Lagoon and Jepun sites were quite different from what we’d seen in the north, full of beautiful crinoids of every imaginable color, swaying in strong currents. We spotted a very large black frog fish, anemone frab, and a long snout sea horse, but the crinoids and the very different coral cover for me were the real memorable feature of these dive sites.
PA172970.jpeg



PA183166.jpeg


The next day we dove Gili Tepekong and Gili Mimpang, which had a lot of pelagics and the densest fish schools I saw on the trip. There were a couple of white tip reef sharks circling around as well. The water was cold below the thermocline, around 69 degrees, and we hung out looking for molas for about 10 minutes, but they did not make an appear ace, Visibility was low and currents/surge were strong, which the guides attributed to the full moon. The highlight for me at these strange dive sites was seeing a zebra moray hunting.
On the whole, I think the Candidasa area is worth diving, but if I went back I’d definitely look for a different dive operator. I would not under any circumstances stay in the Padang Bai area, because the beach and the harbor, while graced with golden sand and lovely topography, are absolutely covered in trash, which the town makes zero effort to clean up. It’s also a ferry terminal and you can see people getting off the ferry looking in horror at the garbage on the beach. In Pemuteran, the dive shop owner told me that the Pemuteran beach also used to be like that, until the town got together and paid 3-4 locals to clean the beach several times daily. The Pemuteran beach is quite lovely as a result. Padang Bai should do the same.

DIVING IN NUSA PENIDA (1 dive day)

We had left Nusa Penida for the end of the trip, as it was known for challenging conditions, and we could dive it out of Sanur, closer to the airport. We stayed at the very atmospheric and well located Puri Santrian hotel in Sanur, and dive with a Bali Scuba, an Australian-owned shop which we recommend highly. Super friendly, superorganized, super competent — the mirror image of the German-owned operator in Candidasa,

We did a three tank trip, which is standard for operators coming from the Sanur area. The first dive was at Manta Point, and it was epic. We arrived later than other boats on the site, and there were at least a dozen other boats with divers in the water. We got in to find cold and murky water at a shallow manta cleaning station and almost immediately, a manta passed over our heads. However, our very competent guide signaled us to mobpve to a deeper cleaning station, and we went down to about 65 feet. The guide pointed out a spot where about a dozen blue spotted rays were piled on top of each other, and while I filemed the,, my wife yanked in my fins, and pointed to a manta that had arrived at the cleaning station and was just contentedly hovering there. I got a 4-minute clip of the encounter, which felt like 40 minutes:


Our second dive was at Crystal Bay, where all the boats from the manta site had moved for the second dive in search of molas. The water here was at 67 degrees from the moment we got in. We had 5 mm wetsuits with hooded vests, and could tolerate the cold, but there were divers in the water with 3 mm suits, and one diver with no wetsuit at all, which was just crazy. The molas were unfortunately a no-show, and this was a pretty bare site without molas, so we spent most of our time watching the scantily clad divers getting hypothermic. Molas were one of the main reasons we had booked the Bali trip in the first place, though months earlier I had lucked out and seen a dozen molas ina single dive in the Galapagos, so I could live with the disappointment, and was only sorry that my wife didn’t get to see them for the first time.

Our third dive was a drift over a gorgeous reef called Mangroves, which had pristine coral cover. On this dive a manta passed over our guide’s head, and the other two divers from our boat caught a glimpse of a rapidly passing whale shark. We really loved this dive site, so much so that we decided that this would be the last dive of the trip. We had left open the possibility of another dive day, but by this point in the trip we had done 27 dives and the idea of spending a last day getting massages and relaxing before the return trip seemed more appealing.

WHAT WE WOULD HAVE DONE DIFFERENTLY: Not much. I would have loved to have dived an extra day at Nusa Penida, diving local sites away from the manta/mola fleet of dive boats. My wife wasn’t thrilled with the diving at Candidasa, and said that if she needed to cut something from the trip, it would have been that. My wife also thought that staying at 5 different places was a bit much, though she had great things to say about each of the places we were at, and I personally thought it was just right,

We brought all our own gear on this trip, and while most dive operators provided full gear rental at modest cost (around $15 a day), we like diving our own gear, and we prefer to spend the $15 paying tips for resort staff to lug our own dive gear around.

There are two things we didn’t like about Bali, and they are facts of life there. The first is the air pollution, partly as a result of traffic and diesel engines, but mainly as a result of locals burning vegetation and garbage. We both caught minor colds on the long flights to Bali, but those colds became dry hacking coughs because of the pollution. On the return flight out of Bali, it was striking how many people had identical dry coughs, this is not a place for asthmatics,

The second thing is the constant threat of getting hit by a scooter while walking on any street. The traffic can be horrendous in Ubud in particular, but even in small towns, everyone gets around in scooters. We saw kids as young as 8 driving scooters, teens looking at their cell phones while driving them, and in heavy traffic, lots of scooters trying to save time by climbing such narrow sidewalks as there are on village streets, which sometimes is no sidewalk at all. So you just need to be hyper alert whenever you’re walking around for scooters. I lived in Taiwan for a year many moons ago, and used to drive a scooter myself. Bali traffic and scooters are in a class by themselves,

Overall, though, Bali is just an amazing place. The only place that compares in terms of great diving and cultural riches at low prices is Egypt. Hope this was helpful, and happy to answer any questions.

IMG_3099.jpeg
 
Glad you had a great trip and it was super nice bumping into both of you in Amed. Normally, there is little to no current in Amed; but of course there are exceptions. "Rasta" Kadek is quite a character...maybe the best hair on the island! For diving Padang Bai, I would recommend locally-owned and operated Gecko Dive...really good shop. As you saw, the diving around Bali is really quite varied and one can see many different marine environments without leaving the island. If you get back this way, let me know and we'll do some diving together.
 
Nice report !

Happy to read that I am not the only to enjoy Pemuteran / Menjangan ! A possibility to avoid the very long drive from Denpasar is to fly to Banyuwangi, and then catch the short ferry ride to Gilimanuk.

And yes Geko in Padangbai are great, I have been diving with them for more than 20 years, and am always happy to come back !
 
Is that Mt. Agung in the background?
Big time. :) As JonnieB points out, one of the advantages of Amed is that the volcano is clearly visible from there. It’s visible in Tulamben and Kubu as well but tends to be obscured by vegetation. In Amed it feels like Agung is following you around everywhere. I like that picture that I posted because it looks like the volcano is erupting on a windy day.
 
@nippurmagnum I enjoyed reading through your trip report. Great pics and lots of good info. I visited Bali back in October 2008, and the place was a sleepy little island back then. The airport in Kuta was tiny and open-air with no air conditioning. Fast forward to my second visit in October 2023, and much has changed. I didn't do any diving on the second trip.

Your write-up makes a strong case for Tulamben and the muck diving. Thanks for the heads up about Diving Candidasa dive shop and your description of the Nusa Penida diving. My dive buddies and I are looking at visiting Bali in September/October 2025, and I'll show them your report to get the juices flowing. My buddies want to go to Lembeh, but if the muck diving is great in Tulamben then less reason to go to Lembeh (for reason that domestic air travel takes up a lot of resources).
 

Back
Top Bottom