If you are a warmer water diver I think they are really great. I have about 75 dives on mine. As others have said the inflator can be bumped on accident, I've only ever had this done on a dive boat where it didn't really matter. The pockets are great and it is really comfortable even with a tank on. If you are diving cold water you might get past the storable weight allowed on the BCD, I just used a weight belt in that case. I can see if you are transiting from rec to tec where it wouldn't be ideal but for a standard rec diver they are fine BCDs.\
Also the tank strap design is really convenient and easy to use.