Have to agree about Anilao Pier night dive.You won't be disappointed, believe me.
Try a night dive at Anilao Pier, insist that they dive it because it can be a long way almost the opposite of Buceo place (probably 30mn boatride) but it's really worth it IMO.
one of the best night dives i have ever done and i am not a night dive fan. Saw many Mimic octopus & squid.
One advantage of staying at Club O, the pier dive is not too far away for a night dive.