Our Non diving time is spent eating. Cuatro Tacos was our new food find last week. 4 tacos for $7 and $2.50 beer. Your choice of about 8 taco variations plus a taco of the day. So good we ate there our last 2 days in a row. Steak, steak and sausage, green chille, and rib were probably my favorites. If your a guacamole fan, their Carribbean Guac is an entirely new twist on an old standard. We had it both days as well. CT is next to lobster shack behind the Thirsty Cougar. Same owners at Lobster shack, kondeza, and kinta, I believe. If so, that explains why it is so good.
Across the street is Cofee De Cozumel. Best coffee shop I've ever been in. Perfect coffee selections. Amazing desserts, don't miss the banana cake.
Guidos is a favorite for a white table cloth restaurant. The scallops are always good, the blackened Snapper and grouper were very good too. La Chef is a must stop for the lobster bacon sandwich. Unless you have a shell fish allergy, don't misss it. Try the lobster rolls at The Lobster Shack and make your own decision as to the never ending debate as to which is better.
It sounds like you will be close to Burritos Gordito and King Burrito, great quick lunch food and cheap. Also, Zermatt is our favorite bakery for breakfast pastries, cookies, and snacks. It's next to Both burrito places.
La Choza has lots of fans...but I'm not crazy about it. Good food no doubt....but the lobster at La Perlita is cheap,and our hands down our favorite place to eat. The coconut crusted lion fish or lionfish ceviche is amazing...but...the population check on the lionfish has made it difficult to get in volume on a regular basis. We ordered LF at 2 restaurants last week and both were out.
For drinks, we usually hit The Thirsty Cougar. Christian is one of the best bartenders and Neko is an amazing waiter. Once the cruise ships leave, it's a great place. On the weekends, the House band Deja Vu plays and they are great. Kind of a cross between the Spanish guitar of the Eagles doing modern American rock. You just have to hear it to understand. Be warned...listening to Deja Vu will lead to a longer night than you planned. Between the music, the sea across the street, and great Mojitos....it's a great way to kill a weekend evening.
If you go East from the SE corner of the square, you will come across Michoacán. They make their own Jorchata like drinks and the pina colada is really good for non-alcoholic refreshment. My personal favorite is the vanilla ice cream bars. (Non chocolate dipped)
We have always wanted to go to the east side, the tequila tour, pearl farm, I believe there is a chocolate company as well, not to mention look at real estate....but it seems diving and eating is all we manage to accomplish. Still not a bad way to spend your days.
Other than the late night $1 hotdogs next to Casa Mexicana, ( we usually hi a couple every trip and have had no issues...they're pretty good and convenient for us when we stay there) that's pretty much all our high points. A brief search on this site, or checking out Christi's list at Blue XTSea divings site will lead to some other options. I'll save you the google search:
Christi’s Cozumel Restaurants List - Blue Xt Sea Diving
Good luck, safe travels.
Jay