47 meters down

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

oh boy....here we go again....
 
I saw this movie last summer, when it was called In The Deep.

Lots of face-palm moments with the expected inaccuracies, which make it somewhat entertaining.

Ex: when the captains says he didn't put extra
'Tanks' in the cage because he didn't want to cause nitrogen narcosis.
 
Seriously how long can their ordeal in the water last? 80lb tank with some air already gone on top of being panicked at 150'...15 minutes, tops? I'd be more worried about the lung overexpansion injury they are probably about to get rather than the sharks. But I know, Hollywood
 
Just glad to see I'm not the only one. Sad thing is, if I were to see this preview before my cert I'd think twice. Might be silly but just being honest.
 
I read this review on IMDB;

1. When plunging to 47 meters and not equalizing the divers would have suffered severe barotrauma, there would be a lot of screaming from the pain of ruptured eardrums.

2. At 47 meters their air would have lasted around 10 minutes given their levels of exertion and constant blabbering.

3. At 47 meters they would have gone into deco within 5 or so minutes, so surfacing the diver at the end of the movie would have caused a DCI – which by the way is not nitrogen bubbles in the brain – it is when nitrogen bubbles come out of solution and can occur anywhere in the body – she probably would have died anyway.

4. For a new scuba diver, with no fins and not using her BCD, her buoyancy was perfect, breathing had no impact on her buoyancy – someone needs to teach me how to do that.

5. When both sisters change cylinders they do it underwater without depressurizing the system – they should both be entered into the Guinness Book of World Records as being the strongest beings on planet Earth and probably within the known universe.

6. When Taylor says he didn't send down the additional tanks initially as he didn't want to cause nitrogen narcosis, the writer once again showed his ignorance for basic scuba. Chances are that at 47 meters they were both narced anyway and changing a cylinder would have made no difference.

7. When Kate sees the new cylinders coming down she says "oxygen cylinders", really, 100% oxygen at 47 meters, no need to worry about sharks the oxygen toxicity would have finished the job.

8. I'm impressed with the speed they could swim under the water with no fins, must be their super human blood that gives them their limit need to breathe and Super girl strength.

I love the line from Kate, "the shark has punctured my BCD and I'm losing air." If she was losing air through a BCD puncture the BC would have already been self-inflating and she would have been positively buoyant throughout the entire movie.

With this and other obvious errors, unless the sharks had teeth made of Kryptonite the girls had nothing to fear.

Anyway, the movie was a really good laugh and showed that no one on set had any dive experience. If they ever make a sequel, and heaven forbid that, they should consider hiring a dive pro to look at the story line first.
 
I read this review on IMDB;

1. When plunging to 47 meters and not equalizing the divers would have suffered severe barotrauma, there would be a lot of screaming from the pain of ruptured eardrums.

2. At 47 meters their air would have lasted around 10 minutes given their levels of exertion and constant blabbering.

3. At 47 meters they would have gone into deco within 5 or so minutes, so surfacing the diver at the end of the movie would have caused a DCI – which by the way is not nitrogen bubbles in the brain – it is when nitrogen bubbles come out of solution and can occur anywhere in the body – she probably would have died anyway.

4. For a new scuba diver, with no fins and not using her BCD, her buoyancy was perfect, breathing had no impact on her buoyancy – someone needs to teach me how to do that.

5. When both sisters change cylinders they do it underwater without depressurizing the system – they should both be entered into the Guinness Book of World Records as being the strongest beings on planet Earth and probably within the known universe.

6. When Taylor says he didn't send down the additional tanks initially as he didn't want to cause nitrogen narcosis, the writer once again showed his ignorance for basic scuba. Chances are that at 47 meters they were both narced anyway and changing a cylinder would have made no difference.

7. When Kate sees the new cylinders coming down she says "oxygen cylinders", really, 100% oxygen at 47 meters, no need to worry about sharks the oxygen toxicity would have finished the job.

8. I'm impressed with the speed they could swim under the water with no fins, must be their super human blood that gives them their limit need to breathe and Super girl strength.

I love the line from Kate, "the shark has punctured my BCD and I'm losing air." If she was losing air through a BCD puncture the BC would have already been self-inflating and she would have been positively buoyant throughout the entire movie.

With this and other obvious errors, unless the sharks had teeth made of Kryptonite the girls had nothing to fear.

Anyway, the movie was a really good laugh and showed that no one on set had any dive experience. If they ever make a sequel, and heaven forbid that, they should consider hiring a dive pro to look at the story line first.


They probably hired a dive pro. Once the pro turned it into a short film they rethought hiring a dive pro.
 
When I saw the trailer last week, my initial thoughts--which haven't changed--were this will yet be another movie which makes people afraid of sharks, less likely to participate in ocean-related activities & causes more shark deaths since people won't see them as animals that should be saved.

Just like the ridiculous Shallows movie last year.
 

Back
Top Bottom