Which cave has killed the most divers?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Just having the thread title gives a bad rap to cave diving for the uninformed people who might frequent this board. This is the type of thing that influences public opinion in a negative light towards something that I love to do.
I think you are entirely missing the point of these objections.
@CAPTAIN SINBAD

I've been in caves, have you? Your past record indicates that you like to light fuses and throw things with a "who me?" attitude. I mostly find your insightfully loaded questions rather amusing. Not this time.

I personally have no business in a cave without an instructor or guide as part of my team. Caves are the only time that "team" means anything at all to me. Caves require a whole new level of self-discipline and training. Been there. Not really my cup of tea, I so love the ocean.

The whole idea is that people no longer have to die in caves. Many dedicated divers who love caves worked endlessly to open closed caves, petition landowners for access, volunteer time and money to keep them clean and open. I'm a continuous member of the NFSA. Why? I may never dive there again, but they really spoke to my condition.

People who just live their own flavor of local diving, just wanting to be allowed to dive locally and keep the caves open...
 
Only if more people lost their lives in "the most dangerous cave"--whatever that may mean--than any other cave.
Huh?
There are dangerous caves that have unstable boulder chokes, slopes with loose gravel and stuff like that. Stuff that could trap you. You don't have many accidents in those because hardly anyone wants to dive there though.

I'm not sure I understand what you were trying to say.
 
Huh?
There are dangerous caves that have unstable boulder chokes, slopes with loose gravel and stuff like that. Stuff that could trap you. You don't have many accidents in those because hardly anyone wants to dive there though.

I'm not sure I understand what you were trying to say.
I think that's what he was saying.
 
Ginnie and/or Peacock would probably be able to make that claim, but we have to remember that they are arguably the most trafficked caves in Florida, so are you just counting number of deaths, or are you normalizing against number of dives?

Exactly. In the same way that Florida has more shark attacks than Rhode Island...more people in the water.
 
I know there's a grate closing off the caves leading off the Ballroom at Ginnie, as apparently too many divers had died in them. When was the grate installed? Just curious.
 
Would you care to explain the reason for this thread?.

Sure. Now that a lot of people have had the chance to interpret this question and respond to it based on their personal interpretation I can tell you what prompted the thread.

I am helping someone co-write / re-write a movie script. The hero of the story is an old mountain climbing legend who is recovering from an alcohol problem. He is sponsored by a millionaire Presidential candidate to climb K-2, the killer mountain as part of a reality show. He does not understand why he has been chosen since he is an out of shape alcoholic but he is told that they want someone to die up there to generate ratings. The challenge motivates him to fight his alcohol addiction and he springs back in shape to go up there and live.

When the expedition begins he finds out that his real mission isn't to reach the top but to locate the dead body of a climber who died on Abruzzi spur and recover a map from him. This map then leads to the rest of the story which I am not going to mention.

In short script has potential but in order for it to work, the sequences needed to be shot in Pakistan at the real location of K-2 on Abruzzi spur. The problem is that K-2 is not an ideal location to film because while the military operation has eliminated a lot of Taliban militancy, safety of the film crew can not be guaranteed. Government is also hanging by the thread so filming the action sequences in Abruzzi spur may not be possible.We have the option of looking for a different mountain but other candidates (including Everest) are no where near as scary as K2 "The Killer Mountain." Only the best of the best climbers attempt to climb K-2 and one in four of them die.

I was looking for way to re-invent the script so that the cinematic situation changes to something more do-able. As a passing thought the screen writer flirted with the idea of replacing mountain with a submerged cave and the mountain climber being a cave diver. The producer and the studio interested in producing this want a real cave that has killed people. In other words "Killer Mountain" must be replaced by "Killer Cave" if there is such a thing and it must be a real place just like K-2 is a real mountain.

This is why I asked if Cave Diving has an equivalent of K-2 and since a direct comparison would not make sense I kept my question open to interpretation. Let people read into it and write whatever comes into their minds.
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/perdix-ai/

Back
Top Bottom